Case 32

Lesson 2: Give It the Right Source and a Clear Ask (Context and Narrow the Ask)

Scenario

Answers often go wrong because AI fills gaps with guesses or uses the wrong version of a document. This lesson practises naming the source of truth, saying which source wins, and describing what a good result looks like.

Why this framework

Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.

Example context

Travel policy (version dated 1 April this year), clause 4.2: "Standard class rail travel must be booked at least seven days ahead. First class is not reimbursed unless approved in writing by a director before travel." Clause 5.1: "Meals are reimbursed up to £25 per day when travelling overnight; receipts are required." Clause 6.3: "Taxis are permitted only where no public transport is available after 9pm." Travel FAQ (older, last updated last year): "You can book first class if the fare is within 20% of standard." Staff question: "I need to go to Manchester next week for a client meeting. Can I book first class because it is only slightly more expensive, and will my dinner be covered?"

Prompt

Purpose: Draft an answer to a staff question about our travel expense rules.
Context: Use only the attached travel policy, version dated this year. If the policy and the FAQ disagree, the policy wins; point out the clash.
Narrow the ask: Under 100 words, quote the relevant clause, and tell the staff member to ask Finance if the policy does not cover their case.

Exercise: Run the prompt with and without the source rule. Note what changes.

Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Travel policy (version dated 1 April this year), clause 4.2: "Standard class rail travel must be booked at least seven days ahead. First class is not reimbursed unless approved in writing by a director before travel." Clause 5.1: "Meals are reimbursed up to £25 per day when travelling overnight; receipts are required." Clause 6.3: "Taxis are permitted only where no public transport is available after 9pm."
Travel FAQ (older, last updated last year): "You can book first class if the fare is within 20% of standard." 
Staff question: "I need to go to Manchester next week for a client meeting. Can I book first class because it is only slightly more expensive, and will my dinner be covered?"

Example output from ChatGPT

1. With the source rule (recommended)

For your Manchester trip, first-class rail travel is not reimbursed based on price alone.

Clause 4.2 of the Travel Policy (1 April 2026) states: "First class is not reimbursed unless approved in writing by a director before travel." Standard-class tickets must also be booked at least seven days ahead.

For dinner, clause 5.1 states: "Meals are reimbursed up to £25 per day when travelling overnight; receipts are required."

The older FAQ's 20% fare exception conflicts with the current policy, which takes precedence.

If your circumstances are not covered, please ask Finance before booking.

2. Without the source rule (illustrative output)

You can book first class if the fare is within 20% of the standard-class fare, as stated in the travel FAQ.

Dinner expenses are reimbursed up to £25 per day, provided you keep your receipts.

Please book your travel in advance and check with Finance if you have any questions.

This is an illustrative weaker response, not a verified result from a separate model run.

3. What changes?

AreaWith source ruleWithout source rule
First-class travelRequires prior written director approvalIncorrectly permits the 20% exception
DinnerOnly covered for overnight travelOmits overnight condition
Source conflictExplicitly identifiedOverlooked
ReliabilityFollows current policyRisks misleading staff

Key lesson: A source hierarchy is not just about improving accuracy. It determines which information the AI is allowed to trust when documents conflict.

In this example, the older FAQ contradicts clause 4.2. Without an explicit source rule, an AI response could apply an outdated exception and give staff incorrect guidance about reimbursement.