Case 31
Lesson 1: Say What It's For (Purpose)
Scenario
A team member asks AI to summarise a report and gets a generic summary nobody uses. The fix is to say what the summary is for and who will read it.
Why this framework
Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.
Example context
Quarterly report (extract), Q3, Tamar Logistics: Revenue £22.4m, up 3% on last quarter, 1% below plan. Margin 11.2%, down from 12.0%, mainly due to fuel and agency driver costs. Three issues need a decision. 1) Whether to renew the Plymouth depot lease (£410k a year, expires in March) or move to a shared site at an estimated £330k. 2) Whether to approve £650k for new route planning software, with payback estimated at 20 months. 3) Whether to pause the graduate scheme for one year, saving about £120k. On-time delivery was 94.1% against a 95% target. Customer complaints fell 8%.
Prompt
Weak: Summarise this report.
Better:
Purpose: Summarise this quarterly report for the executive committee so they can decide on the three issues needing a decision.
Context: Use the attached report as the source of truth.
Narrow the ask: Five bullets and a recommendation.
Exercise: Take a prompt you used this week. Rewrite it with one sentence saying what the result is for and who will read it. Compare the two answers.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Quarterly report (extract), Q3, Tamar Logistics: Revenue £22.4m, up 3% on last quarter, 1% below plan. Margin 11.2%, down from 12.0%, mainly due to fuel and agency driver costs. Three issues need a decision. 1) Whether to renew the Plymouth depot lease (£410k a year, expires in March) or move to a shared site at an estimated £330k. 2) Whether to approve £650k for new route planning software, with payback estimated at 20 months. 3) Whether to pause the graduate scheme for one year, saving about £120k. On-time delivery was 94.1% against a 95% target. Customer complaints fell 8%.Example output from ChatGPT
The difference between the weak and better prompts is purpose and audience. The weak prompt asks for a summary. The better prompt asks for information that helps an executive committee make three decisions.
1. Answer to the weak prompt
Prompt: "Summarise this report."
Tamar Logistics reported Q3 revenue of £22.4m, up 3% from the previous quarter but 1% below plan. Margin fell from 12.0% to 11.2%, mainly due to higher fuel and agency driver costs.
On-time delivery was 94.1%, below the 95% target, while customer complaints fell 8%.
The company is considering renewing its Plymouth depot lease, investing in route planning software, and pausing its graduate scheme to reduce costs.
2. Answer to the improved prompt
Prompt: "Summarise this quarterly report for the executive committee so they can decide on the three issues needing a decision. Five bullets and a recommendation."
Tamar Logistics - Q3 Executive Decision Brief
- Financial performance: Revenue reached £22.4m (+3% quarter-on-quarter), but was 1% below plan. Margin declined by 0.8 percentage points to 11.2%, driven mainly by fuel and agency driver costs.
- Operational performance: On-time delivery was 94.1%, missing the 95% target by 0.9 percentage points. Customer complaints fell 8%.
- Decision 1 - Plymouth depot: Renew the existing lease at £410k annually or consider a shared site estimated at £330k. Potential annual saving: £80k, before relocation and transition costs.
- Decision 2 - Route planning software: Approve or defer a £650k investment with an estimated 20-month payback. The business case needs validation, particularly the expected operational savings.
- Decision 3 - Graduate scheme: Pause recruitment for one year to save approximately £120k, balanced against the potential impact on the future talent pipeline.
Recommendation: Prioritise reviewing the shared-site option for Plymouth, subject to a full relocation cost and service-impact assessment. Request validation of the software payback assumptions before approving £650k. Keep the graduate scheme decision open until the workforce and longer-term capability impacts are assessed.
These are provisional recommendations based only on the report extract.
3. Compare the two answers
| Dimension | Weak prompt | Improved prompt |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | General reader | Executive committee |
| Focus | What happened | What needs deciding |
| Financial information | Reports figures | Connects figures to decisions |
| Structure | Narrative summary | Five decision-focused bullets |
| Next action | Unclear | Three decisions and a recommendation |
| Usefulness | Good for awareness | Better for decision-making |
4. Exercise - Rewrite a prompt from this week
Original prompt:
"Summarise this quarterly report."
Rewritten with one additional sentence:
"Summarise this quarterly report. The result is for the executive committee to review before its next meeting and decide whether to approve, defer or reject the three proposals."
What changes?
The revised prompt makes the output more useful because the model now knows:
- Who will read it: The executive committee.
- What they need to do: Make three decisions.
- What matters: Costs, trade-offs, risks and recommended actions.
Key lesson
A good prompt doesn't just describe the task. It explains what the output will help someone do.
A simple sentence can make a substantial difference:
"This result is for [audience] to [decision or action]."
That changes a generic response into one shaped around the reader's actual needs.
