Case 33

Lesson 3: When to Add More (Persona, Examples, Verification, Review, Tweak and Test)

Scenario

PIN covers most everyday work. When the consequence rises, add the rest of PINPOINT: a professional stance, examples of good and bad, a self-check, your own review before use, and changing one thing at a time. This lesson shows the same task at both levels.

Why this framework

Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.

Example context

Fee schedule (current, effective 1 March): Business current account monthly fee rises from £12 to £15. Card transaction fee stays at 0.4%. Paper statements rise from £2 to £3 per statement; online statements remain free. Existing clients receive the change automatically, with no action needed unless they wish to switch to online statements to avoid the paper charge or close the account. Clients must give 30 days' notice to close without penalty, so notice must be received by 29 January to avoid the new fee. Client: Maple and Finch Bakery Ltd, contact Dana Whitlock. Relationship manager: Sam Rowe.

Prompt

Purpose: Draft a short note to a client explaining a fee change.
Context: Use the attached fee schedule as the final word.
Narrow the ask: Under 150 words, plain language, effective date and what the client needs to do.

Persona and role: Write as an experienced relationship manager: clear, fair, no sales language.
Examples: Good: "From 1 March, the monthly account fee changes from X to Y." Bad: "We are excited to announce enhancements to our pricing."
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing.
Before I use it: I will check every figure against the fee schedule and save this prompt with a version number.
Tweak and test: if the tone is wrong, I will change only the persona and run it again.

Exercise: Decide whether your own task is low, medium or high consequence, and add only the steps it needs.

Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Fee schedule (current, effective 1 March): Business current account monthly fee rises from £12 to £15. Card transaction fee stays at 0.4%. Paper statements rise from £2 to £3 per statement; online statements remain free. Existing clients receive the change automatically, with no action needed unless they wish to switch to online statements to avoid the paper charge or close the account. Clients must give 30 days' notice to close without penalty, so notice must be received by 29 January to avoid the new fee. Client: Maple and Finch Bakery Ltd, contact Dana Whitlock. Relationship manager: Sam Rowe.

Example output from ChatGPT

1. Client note - Version 1.0

Dear Dana,

I’m writing to let you know about changes to the fees for Maple and Finch Bakery Ltd’s business current account.

From 1 March:

  • Your monthly account fee will increase from £12 to £15.
  • Paper statements will increase from £2 to £3 per statement.
  • Card transaction fees will remain at 0.4%.
  • Online statements will remain free.

You do not need to take any action. The changes will apply automatically.

If you would like to avoid paper statement charges, you can switch to online statements.

If you prefer to close your account without penalty before the changes take effect, we must receive your 30 days’ notice by 29 January.

Please contact me if you have any questions.

Kind regards, Sam Rowe Relationship Manager

2. Source verification

All figures and conditions below come directly from the supplied fee schedule.

Material claimClassificationSource
Monthly fee £12 → £15[Verified Source]Fee schedule
Effective 1 March[Verified Source]Fee schedule
Paper statements £2 → £3[Verified Source]Fee schedule
Card fee unchanged at 0.4%[Verified Source]Fee schedule
Online statements remain free[Verified Source]Fee schedule
No action required[Verified Source]Fee schedule
30 days' notice by 29 January[Verified Source]Fee schedule

3. Consequence assessment

Medium consequence

This is a financial communication. Incorrect fees or deadlines could influence a client's decisions or cause complaints.

Checks appropriate to this task:

  • Verify all amounts, percentages and conditions against the fee schedule.
  • Confirm the effective year and the 29 January deadline before sending.
  • Check that the client is clearly told their options.

Important issue: [Unverified] The schedule does not specify a year. As today is 2 November 2026, the intended effective date may be 1 March 2027, but the 29 January deadline should be confirmed independently. The note should not be sent until the dates are validated.

No legal review or extensive approval process is assumed necessary for this drafting exercise.

4. Tweak and test

Prompt version: 1.0

If the tone feels too formal, change only the persona instruction to:

Write as a trusted relationship manager who knows the client. Be warm, direct and conversational, while keeping every fee, deadline and condition unchanged.

Keep the context, source rules, facts and output requirements identical. Compare both versions for clarity and tone, then recheck factual accuracy.

Recommendation: Keep Version 1.0 as the baseline. Resolve the date ambiguity before approving the client note.