Case 11
Restructure Options Without Spin
Scenario
You are the Finance Director of a professional services firm considering merging two regional offices. Staff are anxious and rumours are circulating. The Executive Committee wants options, not a recommendation, next week.
Why this framework
Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.
Example context
Invented example. UK professional services firm with offices in Leeds, Bristol and Manchester. Office cost summary (annual): Leeds GBP 410k, lease ends 2027, 38 staff; Bristol GBP 520k, lease to 2030, 45 staff; Manchester GBP 690k, lease to 2029, 72 staff. Average desk use: Leeds 41%, Bristol 55%, Manchester 48%. Headcount data: 155 staff in total, 12 of them in Leeds roles that are location-specific. Savings figures are not given for any option other than the current lease costs. HR consultation guidance: any proposal affecting 20 or more roles requires collective consultation of at least 30 days before decisions; the firm must consider alternatives to redundancy.
Prompt
Purpose: Lay out restructure options for the Executive Committee fairly, so they can weigh them, including the impact on people.
Context: Use the attached office cost summary and headcount data. Treat HR's consultation guidance as the final word on process. Do not invent savings figures; if a number is not in the data, say so.
Narrow the ask: Three to four options including "do nothing". For each: what changes, cost and saving drivers (from the data only), people impact, risks, and what would have to be true for it to work. Then a comparison table. No recommendation.
Persona and role: Act as an independent adviser who respects that real people are affected. Plain language, no euphemisms like "rightsizing".
Example of bad: "Option B unlocks synergies." Example of good: "Option B closes the Leeds office lease in 2027; twelve roles would move or be at risk."
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing. List the assumptions each option depends on.
Before I use it: I will check every figure against the data and run the wording past HR before it goes to the committee.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Invented example. UK professional services firm with offices in Leeds, Bristol and Manchester. Office cost summary (annual): Leeds GBP 410k, lease ends 2027, 38 staff; Bristol GBP 520k, lease to 2030, 45 staff; Manchester GBP 690k, lease to 2029, 72 staff. Average desk use: Leeds 41%, Bristol 55%, Manchester 48%. Headcount data: 155 staff in total, 12 of them in Leeds roles that are location-specific. Savings figures are not given for any option other than the current lease costs. HR consultation guidance: any proposal affecting 20 or more roles requires collective consultation of at least 30 days before decisions; the firm must consider alternatives to redundancy.Example output from ChatGPT
Executive Committee: Office Restructuring Options
Decision briefing | UK professional services firm | Illustrative case
Purpose: Present four options for the Leeds, Bristol and Manchester offices, including retaining the current arrangements. No option is recommended.
Evidence basis: The office cost summary, headcount data and HR consultation guidance supplied. All figures are annual unless stated otherwise.
- Current position
Total office costs
£1.62m Per year
Total employees
155 Across three offices
Leeds lease expiry
2027 First stated expiry
[Verified Source] The figures above come directly from the supplied materials, with total cost calculated as £410k + £520k + £690k.
Office
Annual cost
Staff
Average desk use
Lease ends
Leeds
£410k
38
41%
2027
Bristol
£520k
45
55%
2030
Manchester
£690k
72
48%
2029
Total
£1.62m
155
[Verified Source] Individual office values are supplied. [Inference] Leeds has the lowest reported desk use and the earliest lease expiry. Low desk use alone does not establish that roles or office space can be removed.
Important HR constraint: [Verified Source] The supplied guidance requires at least 30 days of collective consultation before decisions for any proposal affecting 20 or more roles. Alternatives to redundancy must be considered. The guidance does not define precisely what counts as an affected role, so HR must confirm the threshold for each proposal.
- Four restructuring options Option A - Do nothing Baseline
What changes: Retain all three offices and existing staffing arrangements.
Cost and savings: [Verified Source] Current annual office costs total £1.62m. [Inference] No deliberate office-cost reduction results from this option. Future costs are unknown.
People impact: [Inference] No restructuring-driven changes to roles or locations. Existing working arrangements continue.
Risks: [Inference] The firm continues paying for office space with reported desk use between 41% and 55%. The 2027 Leeds lease remains a future decision point.
Assumptions and conditions: Existing leases, office facilities and workforce arrangements remain viable; costs remain affordable; no other organisational changes are required. These are [Assumption], not established facts.
Option B - Reduce space within all three offices
What changes: Explore smaller premises, partial space release or reconfiguration while retaining Leeds, Bristol and Manchester.
Cost and savings: [Verified Source] Annual office costs are Leeds £410k, Bristol £520k and Manchester £690k. [Inference] Potential cost drivers include reduced occupied space and associated operating costs. Actual savings, alteration costs and contractual rights to release space are [Unverified].
People impact: [Inference] Employees may face fewer dedicated desks, altered attendance patterns, temporary disruption or a changed working environment. No role reductions are assumed.
Risks: Insufficient desk availability during peak attendance, reduced collaboration or client-service capacity, and costs of reconfiguring premises. [Inference]
Assumptions and conditions: [Assumption] Existing leases or landlords permit a reduction in space; actual peak occupancy permits it; accessibility, confidentiality and client needs can be maintained. All require validation.
Option C - Close Leeds when its lease ends in 2027
What changes: Explore closing Leeds at lease expiry and relocating eligible work to Bristol, Manchester or approved remote arrangements. The treatment of location-specific work remains unresolved.
Cost and savings: [Verified Source] Leeds currently costs £410k annually. This is the existing cost base, not a verified saving. [Inference] Ending the lease could avoid some future office costs but may create relocation, replacement-space, technology, travel and transition costs. Net savings are [Unverified].
People impact: [Verified Source] Leeds has 38 staff, including 12 in location-specific roles. [Inference] All 38 could be affected by a closure proposal; the 12 location-specific roles need particular assessment. No redundancy count can be established from the data.
Risks: Employee departures, loss of local expertise, disruption to clients, insufficient capacity elsewhere and potential employee-relations consequences. [Inference]
Assumptions and conditions: [Assumption] The lease can end in 2027 without material additional costs; work can transfer or be delivered differently; affected staff have workable alternatives; the firm can maintain services. HR-led consideration of redundancy alternatives and applicable consultation must take place before a final decision.
Option D - Consolidate into two offices, retaining Leeds and Manchester
What changes: Explore exiting Bristol when its lease ends in 2030 and distributing work between Leeds, Manchester and suitable remote arrangements.
Cost and savings: [Verified Source] Bristol currently costs £520k annually and its lease runs to 2030. [Inference] The future Bristol cost base could be reduced after lease expiry, offset by transition and receiving-office costs. Early termination rights, costs and actual net savings are [Unverified].
People impact: [Verified Source] Bristol has 45 staff. [Inference] A full closure could affect all 45, but the number of roles that might relocate, change or become at risk is unknown.
Risks: A long period before potential lease-related savings, relocation pressures, reduced geographical coverage and receiving-office capacity constraints. [Inference]
Assumptions and conditions: [Assumption] The Leeds lease can be renewed or replaced on acceptable terms beyond 2027; Manchester and Leeds can absorb required work; client service can continue; Bristol can be exited on acceptable terms. Each assumption needs evidence.
- Comparison table
The table distinguishes existing cost exposure from verified savings, which have not been provided.
Dimension
A: Do nothing
B: Reduce space
C: Close Leeds
D: Close Bristol
Offices retained
3
3
2
2
Relevant current annual cost
£1.62m total
£1.62m total
Leeds £410k
Bristol £520k
Verified net savings
None identified
Not provided
Not provided
Not provided
First lease timing relevant to change
Leeds 2027
Subject to lease terms
2027
2030
Staff potentially affected
No restructuring-driven changes
Number unknown
Up to 38 in Leeds
Up to 45 in Bristol
Main people concern
Existing conditions remain
Workplace changes
Relocation and possible role risk
Relocation and possible role risk
Main execution challenge
Continued cost exposure
Space and lease flexibility
Maintaining Leeds functions
Managing long lease and receiving capacity
Consultation consideration
No restructuring proposal
HR assessment required
38 staff potentially affected
45 staff potentially affected
[Verified Source] Office costs, lease expiry years, headcounts and the consultation rule come from supplied materials. [Inference] Potential people impacts and implementation challenges are scenario assessments, not confirmed outcomes.
The figures of 38 and 45 are office headcounts, not forecast redundancies.
- Material evidence gaps for Executive Committee review
Evidence required
Why it matters
Status
Lease exit, break, subletting and renewal terms
Determines whether proposed changes are contractually and financially possible
[Unverified]
Cost split between rent, facilities and other charges
Determines what costs could actually be avoided
[Unverified]
Peak desk demand and office capacity
Tests whether remaining or reduced space is sufficient
[Unverified]
Location requirements for the 12 Leeds roles
Determines whether their work can move or remain locally supported
[Unverified]
Employee mobility, contractual location and accessibility needs
Establishes practical and fair alternatives
[Unverified]
Moving, redundancy, technology and transition costs
Needed to calculate net savings and one-off expenditure
[Unverified]
HR assessment of affected roles and consultation requirements
Establishes the correct process before decisions
[Unverified]
- Decision boundary and process
[Verified Source] HR guidance requires consideration of alternatives to redundancy and, where the 20-role threshold applies, collective consultation of at least 30 days before decisions.
[Inference] Options C and D are likely to require particular scrutiny because their proposed closures could affect more than 20 employees. It has not been established how many roles would fall within the formal consultation threshold.
For the Executive Committee: The present evidence permits comparison of strategic choices, but not a reliable comparison of net financial benefit or final workforce consequences.
No preferred option, site closure, redundancy number or net saving is established by this paper.
Before circulation: All financial figures should be checked against the source data, and HR should validate the consultation interpretation, treatment of affected employees and wording of the people impacts.
