Case 12

Stop or Continue Review

Scenario

You sponsor an internal analytics project that is four months late. The team wants another quarter. You need to decide at Monday's steering meeting.

Why this framework

Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.

Example context

Invented example. Analytics project 'Insight Hub' at a mid-sized UK retailer. Original business case goals: (1) single view of customer within 12 months; (2) reduce weekly manual reporting by 60%; (3) enable personalised offers lifting repeat purchase by 3 percentage points. Latest status report (month 15): single customer view live for online customers only (store customers not integrated); manual reporting reduced by 35%; personalisation pilot ran in two regions with a 0.8 point uplift, not statistically conclusive; budget GBP 1.9m of GBP 2.2m spent; forecast to complete needs a further GBP 0.7m and 6 months; two of four key analysts have left; sponsor still supportive.

Prompt

Purpose: Help me decide whether to stop, pause, or continue the analytics project at Monday's steering meeting.

Context: Use the attached original business case and the latest status report. The business case defines what success was meant to be. Ignore money already spent when weighing the future.

Narrow the ask: A table comparing stop, pause and continue against the original goals, then the three questions I should ask the team before deciding. No more than one page.

Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Invented example. Analytics project 'Insight Hub' at a mid-sized UK retailer. Original business case goals: (1) single view of customer within 12 months; (2) reduce weekly manual reporting by 60%; (3) enable personalised offers lifting repeat purchase by 3 percentage points. Latest status report (month 15): single customer view live for online customers only (store customers not integrated); manual reporting reduced by 35%; personalisation pilot ran in two regions with a 0.8 point uplift, not statistically conclusive; budget GBP 1.9m of GBP 2.2m spent; forecast to complete needs a further GBP 0.7m and 6 months; two of four key analysts have left; sponsor still supportive.

Example output from ChatGPT

Insight Hub - Steering Committee Decision Brief

Monday, 2 November 2026 | Month 15 | Decision: Stop, Pause or Continue

Assessment: [Verified Source] Insight Hub has missed all three original success targets. [Inference] There is evidence of partial value, but insufficient evidence to justify unconditional continuation. The decision should depend on future benefits, remaining costs and the team's ability to deliver - not the £1.9m already spent.

  1. Performance against original goals

Original business case

Latest status (month 15)

Assessment

Single customer view within 12 months

Online customers only; stores not integrated

[Verified Source] Incomplete; 3 months late

Reduce weekly manual reporting by 60%

35% reduction achieved

[Verified Source] 25 percentage points below target

Increase repeat purchases by 3 percentage points

0.8-point uplift in two-region pilot; statistically inconclusive

[Verified Source] Target not demonstrated

  1. Options comparison

Stop

Pause

Continue

What changes

Close project; retain usable outputs

Suspend expansion; reassess scope and delivery

Complete remaining scope over forecast 6 months

Original goals

[Inference] Unmet goals remain undelivered

[Inference] Goals deferred; test whether still achievable

[Inference] Opportunity to meet goals, but no assurance

Future cost

[Unverified] Closure costs unknown

[Unverified] Holding and restart costs unknown

[Verified Source] Further £700k forecast

People impact

[Inference] Team redeployed or released from project

[Inference] Capacity may be lost during suspension

[Verified Source] Two of four key analysts have left; replacement capacity unclear

Main risk

[Inference] Lose potential future value

[Inference] Delay benefits and weaken momentum

[Inference] Further spending without achieving targets

What must be true

Existing outputs can be retained or retired responsibly

Clear recovery plan, cost limit and restart criteria

Credible delivery plan, sufficient skills and evidence of measurable benefits

[Verified Source] The sponsor remains supportive. However, the forecast additional £700k exceeds the £300k remaining from the original £2.2m budget by £400k, assuming it is additional to the £1.9m spent. This forecast requires reconciliation.

  1. Three questions before deciding

Benefits: What measurable value are the completed capabilities delivering today, and what credible evidence supports achieving the remaining original targets?

Delivery: With two key analysts gone, what specific milestones, resources and dependencies support the six-month forecast?

Financial case: What are the future costs, risks and expected incremental benefits of stopping, pausing and continuing - including closure, restart and ongoing operating costs?

Decision position

[Inference] Conditional pause is worth considering, not yet recommending. The team should demonstrate that the additional investment offers better future value than the alternatives.

The steering committee should not approve unconditional continuation based solely on sunk costs, sponsor support or an unvalidated forecast.

Decision ownership: The steering committee must weigh the evidence and choose. The three unanswered questions are material to that choice.