Case 60
Shortlist Comparison Without a Verdict
Scenario
After the debrief you still have two strong candidates with different strengths. Priya wants to see them side by side against the brief before she decides.
Why this framework
Uses PIN. It reorganises evidence the team already agreed; the decision stays with the manager.
Prompt
Purpose: Lay out the two finalists side by side against the approved criteria so the hiring manager can weigh the trade-offs.
Context: Use only the attached agreed debrief record and final scorecards. Do not use resumes or notes that were not part of the debrief.
Narrow the ask: A comparison table by criterion with evidence for each candidate, then three trade-offs the manager is choosing between (for example deeper planning experience against stronger stakeholder skills), and what the brief said about that trade-off. No ranking, no recommendation, no personal details beyond the evidence.
