Case 59

Fair Interview Debrief and Calibration

Scenario

The three interviewers' scores for the final two candidates disagree. The senior planner gave one candidate a 5 on problem solving, Finance gave her a 2. The meeting is in an hour and Priya tends to speak first.

Why this framework

Uses full PINPOINT because this is where the hiring decision is shaped, and where anchoring and halo effects do the most harm.

Prompt

Purpose: Prepare an agenda for our hiring debrief so we discuss evidence, not impressions, and the hiring manager can make a well-reasoned decision.

Context: Use only the attached independent scorecards and interview notes, submitted before the meeting, plus the approved hiring brief. The brief defines what we are assessing.

Narrow the ask:
1. A table by criterion and candidate: each interviewer's score, the evidence they wrote, and the gap between highest and lowest score.
2. List the criteria where scores differ by two or more, as discussion items, with a neutral question for each ("What did the candidate say or do that led to this score?").
3. For each score, mark whether it is backed by a specific example in the notes or is an impression without one.
4. For each candidate, the strongest evidence against the current leaning.
5. The weighted totals, shown as an input only.
Suggest a running order where everyone reveals scores at once and the most senior person speaks last.

Persona and role: Act as a neutral debrief facilitator. Do not recommend a candidate.

Examples: Evidence: "Walked through re-planning after a supplier failed, with the steps she took." Impression: "Felt like a great fit".

Check your work: Flag any note or comment that refers to protected characteristics, appearance, accent, or "fit" without a job-related example, and suggest it be set aside. Confirm every quote is from the notes.

Before I use it: The hiring manager makes and records the final decision with reasons, including why if it differs from the weighted totals. Notes and the decision are stored with the vacancy record.

Tweak and test: After the hire, I will compare this debrief with how the decision went and change one part of the agenda for next time.