Case 40
Why We Won or Lost
Scenario
You are Sales Director at Ashby Engineering Services. The team won four and lost six of its last ten large bids. Everyone has a theory, but nobody has looked at the evidence together.
Why this framework
Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.
Example context
Bid summaries and outcomes, Ashby Engineering Services (last ten large bids): B1 Northgate Water, pumping station upgrade, £2.1m: Won. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'strongest site safety plan; price was mid-range'. B2 Ravensmoor Council, depot electrics, £1.4m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'method statement was generic; winner named the site team'. B3 Selby Chemicals, shutdown maintenance, £3.0m: Won. Sales reason: relationship. Client feedback: 'named project manager with shutdown experience'. B4 Coldharbour NHS Trust, plant room refit, £1.8m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'did not address working in a live hospital'. B5 Eastfield Ports, crane power supply, £2.6m: Lost. Sales reason: incumbent advantage. Client feedback: 'incumbent offered a 24-hour response; you offered 48'. B6 Marlow Foods, refrigeration electrics, £0.9m: Won. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'quick, clear answers during clarifications'. B7 Tyne Valley Rail, signalling cabinets, £2.2m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'price 4% higher, but we scored you lower on social value'. B8 Ridgeway Data Centres, UPS maintenance, £1.6m: Won. Sales reason: technical. Client feedback: 'named engineers and clear handover plan'. B9 Halton College, campus lighting, £0.8m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'submission arrived missing the carbon section'. B10 Brookvale Housing, communal heating, £1.9m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'other bidders showed resident communication plans'.
Prompt
Purpose: Find the real reasons we won or lost our last ten bids, so the sales team can change how we bid next quarter.
Context: Use only the attached bid summaries, client feedback notes and the CRM loss reasons. Where the salesperson's reason and the client's feedback disagree, show both.
Narrow the ask: Give me
- A short table: bid, outcome, stated reason, client's reason
- Patterns across wins and across losses
- Three changes to try on the next bids
Bullets, no more than 350 words.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Bid summaries and outcomes, Ashby Engineering Services (last ten large bids):
B1 Northgate Water, pumping station upgrade, £2.1m: Won. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'strongest site safety plan; price was mid-range'.
B2 Ravensmoor Council, depot electrics, £1.4m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'method statement was generic; winner named the site team'.
B3 Selby Chemicals, shutdown maintenance, £3.0m: Won. Sales reason: relationship. Client feedback: 'named project manager with shutdown experience'.
B4 Coldharbour NHS Trust, plant room refit, £1.8m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'did not address working in a live hospital'.
B5 Eastfield Ports, crane power supply, £2.6m: Lost. Sales reason: incumbent advantage. Client feedback: 'incumbent offered a 24-hour response; you offered 48'.
B6 Marlow Foods, refrigeration electrics, £0.9m: Won. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'quick, clear answers during clarifications'.
B7 Tyne Valley Rail, signalling cabinets, £2.2m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'price 4% higher, but we scored you lower on social value'.
B8 Ridgeway Data Centres, UPS maintenance, £1.6m: Won. Sales reason: technical. Client feedback: 'named engineers and clear handover plan'.
B9 Halton College, campus lighting, £0.8m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'submission arrived missing the carbon section'.
B10 Brookvale Housing, communal heating, £1.9m: Lost. Sales reason: price. Client feedback: 'other bidders showed resident communication plans'.Example output from ChatGPT
Ashby Engineering Services: Bid Win/Loss Review
Scope: Last 10 large bids | 4 won, 6 lost | Total bid value: £18.3m
1. Bid-by-bid findings
| Bid | Outcome | Sales reason | Client's reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| B1 Northgate | Won | Price | Strongest safety plan; mid-range price |
| B2 Ravensmoor | Lost | Price | Generic method; no named team |
| B3 Selby | Won | Relationship | Experienced, named project manager |
| B4 Coldharbour | Lost | Price | Live-hospital risks not addressed |
| B5 Eastfield | Lost | Incumbent | Competitor offered 24h response vs 48h |
| B6 Marlow | Won | Price | Fast, clear clarification answers |
| B7 Tyne Valley | Lost | Price | Price 4% higher; weaker social value |
| B8 Ridgeway | Won | Technical | Named engineers; clear handover |
| B9 Halton | Lost | Price | Missing carbon section |
| B10 Brookvale | Lost | Price | No comparable resident communication plan |
2. Patterns
Across wins (4)
- All four clients highlighted delivery confidence, expertise, safety or responsiveness.
- Three wins (B1, B3, B8) highlighted specific evidence of execution capability.
- None explicitly credited the lowest price.
Across losses (6)
- Five of six losses were attributed to price by Sales; client feedback identified other weaknesses in every case.
- Four losses (B2, B4, B9, B10) involved generic, missing or insufficiently tailored submission content.
- B5 exposed a measurable service gap; B7 exposed both price and social-value weaknesses.
Central finding: Sales appears to overattribute losses to price. Client feedback points more strongly towards bid quality, delivery credibility and responsiveness. These are reported reasons, not independently verified causal conclusions.
3. Three changes for next quarter
| Change | Action | Measure |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Tailor every bid | Require site-specific risks, delivery methods and named personnel. | 100% reviewed before submission |
| 2. Introduce a bid-quality gate | Check all scored sections, including carbon, social value and stakeholder communication. | Zero missing mandatory sections |
| 3. Demonstrate delivery confidence | State response commitments, handovers and clarification ownership; address client-specific service requirements. | Track client feedback on delivery confidence |
Recommendation
Prioritise better evidence of delivery over blanket price reductions.
Run these changes across the next ten bids. Capture client feedback separately from salesperson interpretations and compare win rate, quality scores and loss reasons against this baseline.
Evidence limitation: Ten bids reveal useful patterns, but cannot establish which factors caused each decision.
