Case 39
Do Customers Really Need This?
Scenario
You are Product Lead at Fernhill Health, which launched an appointment reminder product nine months ago. Sign-ups are steady but you are not sure people would miss it if it disappeared.
Why this framework
Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.
Example context
Usage summary (Fernhill Health appointment reminders, nine months to October 2026): 214 clinics signed up; 171 active in October. Median clinic sends 640 reminders a month. Clinics that track no-shows report 11.2% before and 8.9% after (self-reported by 38 clinics only). 46% of active clinics have never changed the default message. Weekly log-ins by clinic staff: median 0.4. Customer interviews (12 clinic managers, September 2026): 7 said patients 'expect' a reminder now; 4 said they would go back to phoning patients if it went; 3 said the main value is less admin, not fewer no-shows; 2 could not say what it costs them; 1 said they signed up only because it was bundled with booking software. Cancellation reasons (43 cancellations): 17 'moved to booking system with built-in reminders'; 11 'cost'; 8 'didn't see a difference'; 5 clinic closed or merged; 2 no reason given.
Prompt
Purpose: Give me an honest read on whether customers truly need our reminder product, to guide whether we invest further or rethink it.
Context: Use the attached usage summary, the last round of customer interviews and the cancellation reasons. Where interviews and usage data point different ways, say so rather than choosing one.
Narrow the ask: One page with
- Signs of real need, with the evidence for each
- Signs of weak need, with the evidence for each
- The three questions we should answer next, and how
Plain language, no more than 300 words.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Usage summary (Fernhill Health appointment reminders, nine months to October 2026): 214 clinics signed up; 171 active in October. Median clinic sends 640 reminders a month. Clinics that track no-shows report 11.2% before and 8.9% after (self-reported by 38 clinics only). 46% of active clinics have never changed the default message. Weekly log-ins by clinic staff: median 0.4.
Customer interviews (12 clinic managers, September 2026): 7 said patients 'expect' a reminder now; 4 said they would go back to phoning patients if it went; 3 said the main value is less admin, not fewer no-shows; 2 could not say what it costs them; 1 said they signed up only because it was bundled with booking software.
Cancellation reasons (43 cancellations): 17 'moved to booking system with built-in reminders'; 11 'cost'; 8 'didn't see a difference'; 5 clinic closed or merged; 2 no reason given.Example output from ChatGPT
Fernhill Health: Do customers truly need our reminder product?
Assessment: There is evidence of real need for reminders, but weaker evidence that clinics need Fernhill as a standalone product.
1. Signs of real need
| Signal | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Continued use | 171 of 214 clinics (80%) were active in October. Median usage: 640 reminders monthly. |
| Patient expectations | 7 of 12 managers said patients now expect reminders. |
| Operational value | 4 managers would return to phone calls; 3 valued reduced administration over fewer no-shows. |
| Possible outcome improvement | 38 clinics reported no-shows falling from 11.2% to 8.9% (2.3 percentage points). This is self-reported, not proof of causation. |
2. Signs of weak need
| Signal | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Easy substitution | 17 of 43 cancellations (40%) switched to booking systems with built-in reminders. |
| Unclear value for money | 11 cancellations cited cost; 8 saw no difference. |
| Low engagement | Median weekly staff log-ins: 0.4. This could indicate automation working well, not weak need. |
| Limited differentiation | 46% of active clinics never changed the default message. This may reflect satisfaction or low engagement. |
Evidence tension: Interviews suggest reminders are expected and useful. Usage supports repeated activity, but cancellations suggest clinics may not value a separate reminder product. These findings are compatible, not contradictory.
3. Three questions to answer next
- Do reminders measurably reduce no-shows? Run a controlled comparison across clinics, accounting for baseline differences.
- Will clinics pay separately? Test standalone pricing and willingness to pay, especially among clinics with integrated booking systems.
- What value is hardest to replace? Interview active and cancelled clinics; measure administrative time saved and alternatives available.
Recommendation
Test before investing further. Prioritise proving measurable value and willingness to pay. If clinics value reminders but prefer bundled solutions, reconsider standalone growth and explore integration or partnership models.
Evidence: Supplied usage summary, September interviews and cancellation reasons. No independent validation available.
