Case 17

Due Diligence Question Set

Scenario

You are preparing for due diligence on a payroll services firm. The deal team needs a first question list by Friday, focused on operations and data protection.

Why this framework

Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.

Example context

Information memorandum (extract): Northgate Payroll Ltd, a Leeds-based payroll bureau founded in 2009, processes pay for about 620 UK clients and 48,000 employees. Revenue £14.2m, EBITDA £3.1m. Operations run from two offices with 85 staff. Payroll runs on a licensed third-party platform, with a bespoke bureau portal built in 2016 by a contractor. Hosting is with a UK cloud provider. The memorandum states the firm is "fully GDPR compliant" but gives no detail on breach history, penetration testing or subcontractors. Two clients account for 22% of revenue. It says nothing about disaster recovery testing or staff turnover. Our standard due diligence checklist (headings only): corporate and legal; financial; commercial; operations; IT systems; data protection and information security; HR; insurance; litigation.

Prompt

Purpose: Create a first set of due diligence questions on operations and data protection for a payroll services firm we may acquire.

Context: Use the attached information memorandum and our standard due diligence checklist. The checklist sets the minimum; add questions specific to what the memorandum says or leaves out.

Narrow the ask: A numbered list grouped by theme, no more than 40 questions, each marked as standard or specific to this target, with the reason for the specific ones.

Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Information memorandum (extract): Northgate Payroll Ltd, a Leeds-based payroll bureau founded in 2009, processes pay for about 620 UK clients and 48,000 employees. Revenue £14.2m, EBITDA £3.1m. Operations run from two offices with 85 staff. Payroll runs on a licensed third-party platform, with a bespoke bureau portal built in 2016 by a contractor. Hosting is with a UK cloud provider. The memorandum states the firm is "fully GDPR compliant" but gives no detail on breach history, penetration testing or subcontractors. Two clients account for 22% of revenue. It says nothing about disaster recovery testing or staff turnover.
Our standard due diligence checklist (headings only): corporate and legal; financial; commercial; operations; IT systems; data protection and information security; HR; insurance; litigation.

Example output from ChatGPT

Northgate Payroll Ltd - Initial Due Diligence Questions

Scope: Operations, IT systems, data protection, information security, and related people and contractual risks.

Basis: Information memorandum extract and standard due diligence checklist provided. The checklist headings establish the minimum areas of review but do not prescribe detailed questions.

Classification: [Standard] = routine due diligence question; [Target-specific] = prompted by information or omissions in Northgate's memorandum.

  1. Operations and service delivery

  2. [Standard] Document the end-to-end payroll process, from receiving client instructions through payroll calculation, approval, payment-file generation, statutory submissions and reconciliation.

  3. [Standard] What are the payroll processing accuracy rates, error rates, missed deadlines, client complaints and service-level breaches for the last 36 months? Provide supporting reports.

  4. [Target-specific] How are approximately 620 clients and 48,000 employees distributed across the two offices, teams and payroll processing cycles? Where are the operational bottlenecks or single points of failure? Reason: The memorandum provides aggregate volumes, two offices and 85 staff, but no capacity or operating model information.

  5. [Target-specific] What proportion of operating capacity is used during peak payroll periods, and how much additional volume could be processed without additional staff or infrastructure? Reason: The memorandum gives processing scale but no capacity, productivity or scalability evidence.

  6. [Standard] What controls govern payroll changes, bank-account amendments, employee additions, approval segregation and exception handling?

  7. [Target-specific] What operational dependencies exist on the two clients representing 22% of revenue, including bespoke workflows, service levels, key personnel and termination arrangements? Reason: The disclosed customer concentration creates potential service delivery and continuity exposure.

  8. IT systems and technology dependencies

  9. [Target-specific] Identify the licensed third-party payroll platform, its version, vendor, licence terms, support arrangements, renewal dates and change-of-control provisions. Reason: Northgate depends on a licensed external platform, but the memorandum does not identify the provider or contractual restrictions.

  10. [Target-specific] Who owns the source code and intellectual property rights for the bespoke bureau portal developed in 2016? Provide the contractor agreement, assignment documents and source-code repository access arrangements. Reason: Contractor-developed software creates an ownership and maintainability question that could affect the acquisition.

  11. [Target-specific] How is the bureau portal maintained, patched, tested and supported? Is the original contractor still involved, and what would happen if that support ceased? Reason: The portal's age and contractor-built origins raise questions about support continuity.

  12. [Target-specific] What interfaces connect the bureau portal, payroll platform, client systems, banking services and HMRC submissions? How are failures detected and reconciled? Reason: The two-system architecture is disclosed, but integration controls are not.

  13. [Standard] Provide the IT asset inventory, system architecture, infrastructure lifecycle, technical debt register and three-year technology investment plan.

  14. [Target-specific] Identify the UK cloud hosting provider, hosting locations, service-level commitments, backup arrangements, subcontractors and exit or migration provisions. Reason: Hosting is disclosed without identifying the provider or explaining dependencies.

  15. Business continuity and disaster recovery

  16. [Standard] Provide the current business continuity plan, disaster recovery plan, business impact assessment and incident escalation procedures.

  17. [Target-specific] When were disaster recovery and backup restoration last tested? Provide results, recovery time objectives (RTO), recovery point objectives (RPO), failures and remediation evidence. Reason: The memorandum contains no information on disaster recovery testing.

  18. [Target-specific] Can either office independently maintain payroll delivery if the other office becomes unavailable? What staff, systems and connectivity dependencies would prevent this? Reason: Northgate operates from two offices, but their resilience and operational independence are unknown.

  19. [Target-specific] What contingencies exist if the third-party payroll platform or UK cloud provider experiences a prolonged outage during a critical payroll cycle? Reason: Both are disclosed external dependencies capable of affecting payroll continuity.

  20. [Standard] Provide details of material operational incidents, service outages, missed payroll deadlines and corrective actions over the last three years.

  21. Data protection and GDPR

  22. [Target-specific] Provide evidence supporting the memorandum's claim of being "fully GDPR compliant", including data protection policies, compliance assessments, audit findings and outstanding remediation actions. Reason: The memorandum makes an unqualified compliance claim without supporting evidence.

  23. [Standard] Document Northgate's roles as controller or processor for each processing activity, the lawful bases where Northgate acts as controller, its records of processing activities and its governance arrangements.

  24. [Standard] Provide standard client data processing agreements, privacy notices, employee data handling procedures, retention schedules and deletion practices.

  25. [Target-specific] Provide a register of all personal data breaches and security incidents for the past five years, including ICO notifications, client notifications, investigation outcomes and remediation. Reason: Breach history is not disclosed despite the stated GDPR compliance position.

  26. [Target-specific] Identify every subcontractor or sub-processor with access to payroll or employee personal data, their processing locations, contractual safeguards and approval arrangements. Reason: The memorandum does not identify subcontractors or explain the processing supply chain.

  27. [Standard] How are data subject rights requests, complaints, corrections, deletion requests and client instructions handled? Provide request volumes and performance records.

  28. [Target-specific] What categories of employee personal data are processed, including bank details, National Insurance numbers and any special-category data? What technical safeguards apply to each? Reason: Northgate processes payroll for approximately 48,000 employees, but the memorandum does not describe its data inventory or sensitive-data controls.

  29. [Standard] Provide data protection impact assessments, international transfer assessments, transfer safeguards where applicable, and any correspondence or investigations involving the ICO.

  30. Cybersecurity and information security

  31. [Target-specific] When was the most recent independent penetration test of the bureau portal, payroll interfaces and cloud environment? Provide reports, critical findings, remediation evidence and retest results. Reason: Penetration testing is specifically absent from the memorandum.

  32. [Standard] Describe identity and access management controls, including multifactor authentication, privileged access, joiner-mover-leaver processes and periodic access reviews.

  33. [Standard] Provide vulnerability scan results, patch compliance reporting, endpoint protection arrangements, encryption standards and security monitoring procedures.

  34. [Target-specific] How is client data separated within the payroll platform and bureau portal? Can one client's users or administrators access another client's payroll information? Reason: Processing data for 620 clients creates a material need to establish effective tenant isolation.

  35. [Standard] Provide cybersecurity policies, independent assurance reports, security certifications where held, incident response plans and security awareness training records.

  36. [Target-specific] What monitoring and safeguards protect bulk payroll exports, payment instructions, bank-account changes and privileged access to employee records? Reason: Northgate's payroll processing activities create potential exposure to payment diversion and large-scale personal data disclosure.

  37. People, governance and insurance

  38. [Target-specific] Provide staff turnover, vacancies, absenteeism and retention data for the past three years, broken down by operations, IT and management. Reason: The memorandum identifies 85 staff but omits turnover and workforce stability information.

  39. [Target-specific] Identify employees and external contractors whose departure would materially disrupt payroll processing, portal maintenance, regulatory compliance or client relationships. What succession and knowledge-transfer arrangements exist? Reason: The workforce size and contractor-built technology warrant examination of key-person dependencies.

  40. [Standard] What training, competency assessments, background checks, confidentiality obligations and access restrictions apply to employees handling payroll and personal data?

  41. [Standard] Identify accountable executives for operational risk, information security and data protection, including the DPO arrangements, governance committees and reporting lines.

  42. [Standard] Provide professional indemnity, cyber liability and business interruption insurance policies, coverage limits, exclusions, claims history and renewal information.

  43. Contracts, disputes and acquisition implications

  44. [Standard] Provide material client contracts, service-level commitments, liability caps, indemnities, audit rights, termination provisions and change-of-control clauses.

  45. [Target-specific] For the two clients representing 22% of revenue, are there renewal, termination, consent or change-of-control risks that could disrupt service delivery following acquisition? Reason: Material customer concentration could amplify operational risk during the transition.

  46. [Standard] Provide details of actual, threatened or settled litigation, regulatory investigations and material disputes involving payroll errors, confidentiality, information security or service delivery.

  47. [Target-specific] What contractual, licensing, technology, data migration and regulatory obligations would arise if the buyer integrated Northgate's operations, transferred processing responsibilities or replaced existing systems? Reason: The third-party payroll licence, bespoke portal and cloud hosting arrangements may constrain post-acquisition integration.

Suggested first-round priorities

The following merit early review because they could materially influence valuation, deal terms or post-acquisition integration:

PriorityQuestionsMain concern
Critical8, 9Portal ownership, maintainability and contractor dependency
Critical18, 21, 22Unsupported GDPR compliance claim, breaches and undisclosed sub-processors
Critical14, 16Untested recovery capability and external platform outages
High7, 12, 40Technology licences, supplier contracts and acquisition restrictions
High26, 29, 31Cybersecurity exposure and payroll-data protection
High6, 38Concentrated customer dependencies and retention
High32, 33Staff turnover and key-person dependencies

Evidence standard: All 40 items are diligence questions, not findings of deficiencies. The target-specific reasons refer to [Verified Source] facts or omissions in the supplied memorandum. Any risk arising from those facts is an [Inference] requiring validation.

Recommended next step: Issue this as a first-round information request and ask Northgate to provide documentary evidence, rather than management assurances alone. Have Legal and the data protection lead verify the GDPR and contractual findings before drawing acquisition conclusions.