Case 16
Acquisition Screening Against Criteria
Scenario
You are Head of Corporate Development at a software group. Three small firms have been put forward as acquisition targets. The board has set written acquisition criteria.
Why this framework
Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.
Example context
Invented example. Board-approved acquisition criteria of a UK software company: (1) annual revenue GBP 5m to 20m; (2) recurring revenue above 70% of total; (3) EBITDA margin above 15%; (4) no customer above 20% of revenue; (5) UK or Ireland based; (6) management team willing to stay for at least two years. Target packs (invented): Target A 'Marlow Systems': revenue GBP 8.4m, EBITDA margin 18%, based in Reading, largest customer 27% of revenue, recurring revenue not stated, management retention not stated. Target B 'Tidewater Analytics': revenue GBP 14m, 82% recurring, EBITDA margin 9%, based in Dublin, no customer concentration data, founders 'open to discussion' on staying. Target C 'Greyfriars Labs': revenue GBP 3.1m, 90% recurring, EBITDA margin 22%, based in Edinburgh, largest customer 12%, two-year retention agreed in principle by both directors.
Prompt
Purpose: Screen three potential targets against our board-approved acquisition criteria, so I can recommend which, if any, deserves deeper work.
Context: Use the attached criteria as the final word. Use only the information packs supplied for each target. Do not search for or assume information about the companies.
Narrow the ask: A scoring table: criterion by target, with met, partly met, not met or unknown, and the evidence. Then a short note on deal-breakers and the top questions for each target. Stop and ask if a criterion is ambiguous.
Persona and role: Act as a disciplined corporate development analyst who protects the company from deal enthusiasm.
Example of good: "Recurring revenue share: unknown; the pack gives total revenue only." Example of bad: "Strong recurring revenue model."
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing.
Before I use it: I will check scores against the packs and have Finance review before anything goes to the board.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Invented example. Board-approved acquisition criteria of a UK software company: (1) annual revenue GBP 5m to 20m; (2) recurring revenue above 70% of total; (3) EBITDA margin above 15%; (4) no customer above 20% of revenue; (5) UK or Ireland based; (6) management team willing to stay for at least two years. Target packs (invented): Target A 'Marlow Systems': revenue GBP 8.4m, EBITDA margin 18%, based in Reading, largest customer 27% of revenue, recurring revenue not stated, management retention not stated. Target B 'Tidewater Analytics': revenue GBP 14m, 82% recurring, EBITDA margin 9%, based in Dublin, no customer concentration data, founders 'open to discussion' on staying. Target C 'Greyfriars Labs': revenue GBP 3.1m, 90% recurring, EBITDA margin 22%, based in Edinburgh, largest customer 12%, two-year retention agreed in principle by both directors.Example output from ChatGPT
Acquisition Screening - Board Criteria Assessment
Overall conclusion: None of the three targets currently satisfies all six board-approved criteria on the evidence provided. Marlow Systems is the closest financially but has a customer-concentration breach. Tidewater Analytics falls below the EBITDA threshold. Greyfriars Labs is below the minimum revenue threshold.
All three have at least one confirmed criterion failure. No target should advance as fully compliant without further review or an explicitly approved exception.
- Scoring matrix
All evidence below is [Verified Source] from the supplied fictional target packs and board criteria. Unknown means no sufficient evidence, not failure.
Board-approved criterion
A - Marlow Systems
B - Tidewater Analytics
C - Greyfriars Labs
Revenue £5m–£20m
Met £8.4m
Met £14m
Not met £3.1m
Recurring revenue above 70%
Unknown Not stated
Met 82%
Met 90%
EBITDA margin above 15%
Met 18%
Not met 9%
Met 22%
No customer above 20%
Not met Largest 27%
Unknown Not provided
Met Largest 12%
UK or Ireland based
Met Reading
Met Dublin
Met Edinburgh
Management staying ≥2 years
Unknown Not stated
Partly met Open to discussion
Partly met Agreed in principle
Management classification is [Inference]: discussions and agreements in principle indicate some willingness, but do not establish firm two-year commitments.
- Summary of results
Marlow
3/6 met · 1 failed
Tidewater
3/6 met · 1 failed
Greyfriars
3/6 met · 1 failed
Scores are descriptive, not weighted investment rankings. A single mandatory failure may override the number of criteria met. 3. Deal-breakers and priority questions
Marlow Systems - Conditional investigation
[Verified Source] Largest customer contributes 27% of revenue, exceeding the 20% ceiling by 7 percentage points.
[Inference] Customer concentration is a potential deal-breaker. Attractive revenue and profitability do not offset a mandatory breach.
Priority questions:
What share of revenue is genuinely recurring?
What is the major customer's contract duration, renewal risk and revenue trajectory?
Is management prepared to commit to two years?
Tidewater Analytics - Profitability concern
[Verified Source] EBITDA margin is 9%, six percentage points below the minimum.
[Inference] Improving the margin would require an evidence-backed operational plan; projected improvements do not satisfy today's criterion.
Priority questions:
What explains the 9% margin, and is there documented scope for improvement?
Does any individual customer account for more than 20% of revenue?
Will the founders explicitly commit to remaining for two years?
Greyfriars Labs - Scale constraint
[Verified Source] Annual revenue is £3.1m, £1.9m below the board's minimum.
[Inference] It has the most complete evidence pack and no other stated numerical breaches, but its size makes it non-compliant.
Priority questions:
Is there evidence of a credible path to £5m annual revenue?
What commercial or contractual commitments support that growth?
Can both directors formalise their two-year retention commitments?
- Recommendation for the acquisition committee
[Inference] Do not approve full due diligence on any target as board-compliant at this stage.
Target
Proposed next step
Condition
Marlow
Limited clarification
Establish recurring revenue and retention; assess concentration breach
Tidewater
Limited financial review
Establish margin drivers and customer concentration
Greyfriars
Hold or seek an exception
Confirm whether the board permits sub-£5m acquisitions
Two governance issues to resolve
[Unverified] Are all six criteria mandatory exclusion thresholds? The supplied criteria do not specify whether exceptions are permitted. If they are strict gates, all three targets fail screening.
[Unverified] What evidence is sufficient to establish management's willingness to stay? A formal commitment is not expressly required by the criterion, so the two partly-met scores require consistent interpretation.
These ambiguities could materially change the screening decisions and should be resolved with the board's delegated decision-maker before progressing.
Final screening position: No unconditional shortlist. Marlow and Tidewater warrant only targeted clarification; Greyfriars warrants an exception discussion only if its smaller scale is strategically attractive. No such strategic rationale is established in the supplied packs.
Assessment basis: supplied fictional board criteria and three target information packs only. All proposed actions are analyst inferences, not board approvals. Finance should validate reported figures before escalation.
