Case 07
Board Paper Readiness Check
Scenario
You are the Chief Operating Officer at Harbourline Insurance. Your paper asking the board to approve a two-year replacement of the claims platform goes to the board pack in five days. The Company Secretary has warned that last quarter's paper was sent back for unclear asks.
Draft Paper (excerpt)
The programme replaces the 14-year-old claims system in two phases. Phase one covers motor claims. The total budget is stated in section 4. Risks are summarised in appendix B. The paper asks the board to 'endorse the direction of travel'.
Why this framework
Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.
Example context
Invented example. Draft board paper: 'Customer Portal Programme' for a mid-sized UK regional building society. The draft says: the programme replaces the online servicing portal in two phases; total cost GBP 4.2m over 30 months (phase one GBP 1.5m over 10 months, phase two GBP 2.7m); expected annual running-cost saving of GBP 600k from year 3; 212 complaints about portal outages last year; it asks the board to approve the full GBP 4.2m programme in one decision, describing it as a 'transformation journey'. There is no risk section, no options considered, and no mention of the dependency on the core banking upgrade. The board paper template requires: 1 Decision sought, 2 Strategic fit, 3 Options considered, 4 Financials, 5 Risks and mitigations, 6 Delivery plan, 7 Recommendation.
Prompt
Purpose: Get my board paper ready to submit. The readers are non-executive directors who will spend about ten minutes on it and must decide whether to approve the programme.
Context: The attached draft paper is the only source of truth for the proposal. The attached board paper template sets the required structure. If the draft and the template disagree on structure, the template wins. Do not bring in figures from anywhere else.
Narrow the ask: Give me
1. The decision the board is being asked to make, in one sentence, as you understand it from the draft.
2. Gaps against the template, as a short table.
3. The five questions a sceptical director is most likely to ask, with where the paper answers them or a note that it does not.
4. A rewritten executive summary of no more than 200 words.
Stop and ask me if the decision being sought is not clear from the draft.
Persona and role: Act as an experienced company secretary who protects the board's time. Be direct. Do not soften weaknesses, and do not make the proposal sound stronger than the evidence allows.
Example of what good looks like: "The board is asked to approve phase one spending only, with phase two returning for separate approval." Example of what bad looks like: "The board is asked to note and support the transformation journey."
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing. Confirm every number in your summary appears in the draft.
Before I use it: I will check the summary against the draft and the template myself before it goes to the Company Secretary.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Invented example. Draft board paper: 'Customer Portal Programme' for a mid-sized UK regional building society. The draft says: the programme replaces the online servicing portal in two phases; total cost GBP 4.2m over 30 months (phase one GBP 1.5m over 10 months, phase two GBP 2.7m); expected annual running-cost saving of GBP 600k from year 3; 212 complaints about portal outages last year; it asks the board to approve the full GBP 4.2m programme in one decision, describing it as a 'transformation journey'. There is no risk section, no options considered, and no mention of the dependency on the core banking upgrade. The board paper template requires: 1 Decision sought, 2 Strategic fit, 3 Options considered, 4 Financials, 5 Risks and mitigations, 6 Delivery plan, 7 Recommendation.Example output from ChatGPT
Board Paper Review: Customer Portal Programme Not ready for Board submission
[Inference] The approval request is clear, but the paper does not give non-executive directors enough information to assess the financial commitment, alternatives, delivery risks or a critical dependency. The absence of a risk section and options appraisal is particularly serious.
- Decision sought
[Verified Source] The Board is asked to approve the full £4.2 million Customer Portal Programme, delivered in two phases over 30 months, through a single approval decision.
[Inference] This commits the Board to both phases upfront, rather than reserving phase two for a separate approval.
- Gaps against the Board template
Required section
Assessment
Gap or required correction
- Decision sought
Weak
Full £4.2m approval is stated, but the scope and conditions of authorisation are not defined.
- Strategic fit
Partial
212 outage complaints support a case for action, but strategic alignment and intended customer outcomes are not established.
- Options considered
Missing
No alternatives, including deferral or phased approval, are evaluated.
- Financials
Partial
Costs and expected savings are given, but no evidence supports the savings forecast, payback or cost assumptions.
- Risks and mitigations
Missing
No risk assessment, mitigations or treatment of the core banking upgrade dependency.
- Delivery plan
Partial
Phase durations and costs are provided, but no milestones, accountable owners or approval gates.
- Recommendation
Weak
Approval is requested, but the recommendation is not supported by an options assessment or risk analysis.
Source: supplied draft and seven-section template. [Verified Source] for documented omissions and details; [Inference] for judgements about adequacy. 3. Five questions a sceptical director will ask
Director's question
Where answered
Assessment
- Why approve £4.2m now instead of approving phase one first?
Draft approval request and phase costs
Not answered. [Verified Source] No justification for a single full-programme commitment.
- What alternatives have management assessed, and why is this the best option?
No options section
Not answered. [Verified Source]
- How credible are the £600k annual savings, and when will they be realised?
Draft financial figures
Partially answered. [Verified Source] Savings are forecast from year 3; assumptions and supporting evidence are absent.
- What happens if the core banking upgrade is delayed or fails?
Dependency not mentioned
Not answered. [Verified Source] The impact on cost, delivery and benefits is unknown.
- Who is accountable for delivery, and what would trigger Board intervention?
Two-phase delivery description
Not answered. [Verified Source] No accountable owner, milestones, escalation triggers or approval gates are provided.
- Rewritten executive summary Writing Executive Summary
Decision sought: The Board is asked to approve the full £4.2 million Customer Portal Programme, delivered in two phases over 30 months. [Verified Source]
The programme will replace the Society's existing online servicing portal. The draft records 212 complaints relating to portal outages last year, providing evidence of service issues that the programme seeks to address. [Verified Source]
Phase one is estimated to cost £1.5 million over 10 months, followed by phase two at £2.7 million. Management forecasts annual running-cost savings of £600,000 from year 3. These figures are stated in the draft but their underlying assumptions are not evidenced. [Verified Source]
Material matters remain unresolved. The paper does not assess alternative options, explain the dependency on the core banking upgrade, or provide delivery risks and mitigations. [Verified Source]
Consequently, the available information is insufficient to support an informed decision on the full programme commitment. [Inference]
Recommendation: Defer submission for approval until management provides an options appraisal, a substantiated financial case, a dependency assessment and a delivery risk plan. [Inference]
Summary: 169 words, including claim labels. Every figure is present in the supplied draft; no external figures have been introduced. 5. Material matters to resolve before submission
Priority
Claim or issue
Classification
Required action
Critical
Core banking upgrade dependency
[Verified Source]
Establish timing, ownership, impact and contingency arrangements.
Critical
Full-programme approval is preferable to phased approval
[Unverified]
Provide a reasoned comparison of approval structures.
High
£600k annual savings are achievable
[Unverified]
Validate baseline costs, savings assumptions and realisation timing.
High
£4.2m is a sufficiently robust budget
[Unverified]
Confirm scope, contingency and cost-estimate basis.
High
Programme delivery is achievable within 30 months
[Unverified]
Provide milestones, delivery accountability and risk mitigations.
Company Secretary's recommendation - [Inference]: Return the paper to management before Board circulation. The decision sought is sufficiently clear; the evidence supporting it is not.
Do not silently change the approval request to phase one only. That would alter management's proposal. If phased approval is preferable, management must expressly revise the recommendation and supporting rationale.
Verification: All figures used above come from the supplied draft. No external data, assumptions presented as facts, or invented financial benefits have been introduced.
