Case 57

Structured Interview Kit and Scorecard

Scenario

Six candidates are going to interview. Three interviewers will see each one: Priya, a senior planner and someone from Finance. Last time each asked their own favourite questions and the debrief turned into opinions.

Why this framework

Uses PIN. The criteria are already agreed, so the task is to turn them into consistent questions and anchors.

Prompt

Purpose: Build an interview kit so every candidate for the planning analyst role is asked comparable questions and scored against the same standard.

Context: Use the attached approved hiring brief and job description only. Assign each criterion to one interviewer so we do not all test the same thing.

Narrow the ask: For each criterion:
- Two main questions (past behaviour or a short work-based scenario), plus two follow-up probes.
- What a strong (5), adequate (3) and weak (1) answer would contain, based on the brief.
- Which interviewer owns it.
Then a one-page scorecard: criterion, weight, score 1 to 5, evidence notes. Include a reminder to score independently before the debrief. Avoid questions about personal life, plans for a family, health, age, religion or nationality, and brain-teasers unrelated to the work. Note any adjustments candidates can request.