Case 45
Supplier Shortlist Comparison
Scenario
You are Procurement Manager at Halden Manufacturing. Three suppliers have bid to provide a new maintenance management system. The contract runs five years and switching later would be costly.
Why this framework
Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.
Example context
Requirements list with weightings (Halden Manufacturing maintenance management system): R1 work order and planned maintenance scheduling, 25%; R2 mobile app for engineers that works offline, 20%; R3 integration with our SAP finance system, 15%; R4 five-year total cost, 20%; R5 data export and exit support, 10%; R6 implementation within 6 months, 10%. Bid A, FixPoint: full scheduling; mobile app needs signal ('offline mode on roadmap for 2027'); standard SAP connector; five-year cost £410k; implementation 5 months. Draft clause 14.2: 'On termination, Customer data will be provided in Supplier's proprietary format.' Bid B, AssetLoop: full scheduling; offline mobile app; SAP integration via custom build, £40k included in price; five-year cost £465k; implementation 6 months. Draft clause 11.4: 'Data return on termination is chargeable at Supplier's prevailing day rates.' Bid C, Plantwise: scheduling but planned maintenance limited to 500 assets (we have 820); offline mobile app; SAP connector; five-year cost £380k; implementation 4 months. Draft clause 9.1: 'Prices may be increased annually by RPI plus 3%.' Clause 16.3: 'Customer shall receive a full CSV export of all data within 30 days of termination at no charge.'
Prompt
Purpose: Compare the three shortlisted suppliers and recommend one, for the operations director to approve.
Context: Use the attached bids, our requirements list with weightings and the draft contract terms from each supplier. The requirements list and weightings are the final word on what matters. Do not use information about the suppliers from outside these documents.
Narrow the ask: Give me
1. A scoring table against each weighted requirement, with a one-line reason per score.
2. Contract terms that create lock-in or cost risk, quoted, for each supplier.
3. Questions to put to each supplier before a decision.
4. A recommendation with the main reason and the main risk.
Stop and ask me if a requirement is too vague to score.
Persona and role: Act as an experienced, impartial procurement adviser. Do not favour the cheapest or the best presented bid by default.
Example of what good looks like: "Supplier B scores highest, but its exit clause charges for data return, so negotiate that first." Example of what bad looks like: "All three suppliers are strong partners."
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing. Confirm each quoted clause matches the supplier's draft exactly.
Before I use it: I will have Legal review the flagged clauses and check the scores with the maintenance lead.
If the first version misses the mark, I will change one thing at a time, starting with the scoring reasons.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Requirements list with weightings (Halden Manufacturing maintenance management system): R1 work order and planned maintenance scheduling, 25%; R2 mobile app for engineers that works offline, 20%; R3 integration with our SAP finance system, 15%; R4 five-year total cost, 20%; R5 data export and exit support, 10%; R6 implementation within 6 months, 10%.
Bid A, FixPoint: full scheduling; mobile app needs signal ('offline mode on roadmap for 2027'); standard SAP connector; five-year cost £410k; implementation 5 months. Draft clause 14.2: 'On termination, Customer data will be provided in Supplier's proprietary format.'
Bid B, AssetLoop: full scheduling; offline mobile app; SAP integration via custom build, £40k included in price; five-year cost £465k; implementation 6 months. Draft clause 11.4: 'Data return on termination is chargeable at Supplier's prevailing day rates.'
Bid C, Plantwise: scheduling but planned maintenance limited to 500 assets (we have 820); offline mobile app; SAP connector; five-year cost £380k; implementation 4 months. Draft clause 9.1: 'Prices may be increased annually by RPI plus 3%.' Clause 16.3: 'Customer shall receive a full CSV export of all data within 30 days of termination at no charge.'Example output from ChatGPT
Halden Manufacturing: Supplier Evaluation & Recommendation
PROCUREMENT DECISION BRIEF · 2 NOVEMBER 2026
Recommendation: Select AssetLoop (Supplier B), subject to contract negotiation and technical validation.
[Inference] AssetLoop offers the best overall fit against the six weighted requirements. It meets the stated scheduling and offline requirements, but its custom SAP integration and chargeable data return create risks that need resolving before approval.
1. Weighted scoring comparison
Scoring method: 0–5 for each requirement, where 5 is strongest. The weightings are taken directly from Halden's requirements. [Assumption] The scoring scale, assessment criteria and cost-scoring formula are proposed for this evaluation, not supplied by Halden.
| Requirement | Weight | A: FixPoint | B: AssetLoop | C: Plantwise |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1 Scheduling | 25% | 5 | 5 | 1 |
| R2 Offline mobile | 20% | 0 | 5 | 5 |
| R3 SAP integration | 15% | 5 | 3 | 5 |
| R4 Five-year cost | 20% | 4.63 | 4.09 | 5 |
| R5 Export and exit | 10% | 1 | 2 | 5 |
| R6 Implementation | 10% | 5 | 4 | 5 |
| Weighted total | 100% | 70.5/100 | 82.3/100 | 80.0/100 |
| Rank | 3 | 1 | 2 |
[Assumption] For R4, the score equals 5 × £380k / quoted five-year cost. This preserves proportional cost differences rather than assigning arbitrary cost bands. Other scores use qualitative assessments of compliance and risk.
Weighted evaluation results
0/10025/10050/10075/100100/100AssetLoop (B)Plantwise (C)FixPoint (A)
Provisional scoring. The difference between B and C is only 2.3 points, and C has an unresolved asset-capacity gap.
Reasons behind the scores
| Requirement | Supplier | Reason and evidence |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | A: 5; B: 5; C: 1 | [Verified Source] A/B offer full scheduling. C limits planned maintenance to 500 assets against Halden's 820. |
| R2 | A: 0; B: 5; C: 5 | [Verified Source] A requires signal; offline is only on its 2027 roadmap. B/C support offline. |
| R3 | A: 5; B: 3; C: 5 | [Verified Source] A/C offer SAP connectors; B needs a custom build. [Inference] This adds delivery risk. |
| R4 | A: 4.63; B: 4.09; C: 5 | [Verified Source] Quoted five-year costs: £410k, £465k, £380k. [Inference] C's annual escalation clause makes its cost less certain. |
| R5 | A: 1; B: 2; C: 5 | [Verified Source] A provides proprietary-format data; B charges return fees; C provides free CSV export. |
| R6 | A: 5; B: 4; C: 5 | [Verified Source] A takes 5 months, B 6, C 4. [Assumption] B loses one point for having no schedule buffer. |
Important qualification: [Assumption] These scores assume the bids' descriptions establish basic functional capability. No product demonstrations, SAP test results or contractual acceptance criteria were supplied. Plantwise's 500-asset ceiling should be treated as a possible mandatory-compliance failure, not merely a low score.
2. Contract risks: exact clauses
Supplier A: FixPoint
High exit lock-in risk
Clause 14.2:
On termination, Customer data will be provided in Supplier's proprietary format.
[Verified Source] The clause specifies a proprietary format. [Inference] Halden could need supplier assistance or paid conversion to migrate. The clause does not specify conversion costs.
Action: Negotiate complete, documented, machine-readable export in a standard format at no additional charge.
Supplier B: AssetLoop
High exit cost uncertainty
Clause 11.4:
Data return on termination is chargeable at Supplier's prevailing day rates.
[Verified Source] Data return is chargeable at rates not fixed in the extract. [Inference] This creates potentially significant and difficult-to-budget exit costs.
Action: Require free full data export, including attachments and relevant metadata, plus defined transition assistance rates and service levels.
Supplier C: Plantwise
High price escalation risk
Clause 9.1:
Prices may be increased annually by RPI plus 3%.
[Verified Source] The contract allows increases above RPI. [Inference] The quoted £380k may not represent a fixed five-year total.
Action: Negotiate a clear five-year price schedule and an annual escalation cap.
Clause 16.3:
Customer shall receive a full CSV export of all data within 30 days of termination at no charge.
[Verified Source] This provides the clearest exit right of the three, although export completeness and usability still need validation.
All four quotations have been checked against the exact wording pasted in the materials. No other contractual provisions were provided.
3. Questions before decision
FixPoint: A
Can offline mobile operation be contractually delivered before go-live, with defined acceptance tests?
Can you provide standard-format data export at no additional charge?
What is the fallback if offline functionality is delayed?
AssetLoop: B
What integration milestones and acceptance tests will prove the custom SAP build works within six months?
Is the £40k integration build fully included in the £465k five-year price, including testing and defect resolution?
Will you replace clause 11.4 with free, complete data export and agreed transition assistance?
Plantwise: C
Can the 500-asset planned-maintenance limit be increased to at least 820 before go-live, with adequate future capacity?
What is the full five-year cost after permitted RPI-plus-3% increases?
Can annual escalation be capped, and can full CSV export be demonstrated?
4. Approval recommendation
AssetLoop
Preferred supplier
Five-year bid
£465k
Weighted score
82.3/100
[Inference] AssetLoop has the strongest balanced offer: full scheduling and offline mobile use without Plantwise's asset ceiling or FixPoint's offline gap.
Main risk: Its custom SAP integration has to be completed inside a six-month implementation, leaving no stated schedule buffer. Uncapped data-return charges create additional commercial exposure.
Conditions for approval
- Technical: Maintenance lead validates all 820 assets, offline workflows and SAP integration against written acceptance tests.
- Commercial: Procurement confirms the £465k five-year price includes the SAP build and all required components.
- Legal: Replace the open-ended data-return charging provision with defined export and transition rights.
- Delivery: Obtain a contractual milestone plan, integration test dates, remedies for delay and clear implementation ownership.
[Inference] If AssetLoop refuses reasonable exit protections or cannot substantiate SAP delivery within six months, reopen negotiations with Plantwise, but only if it can remove the 500-asset ceiling and clarify its five-year price.
5. Checks before the director signs
[Unverified] The supplied material does not establish whether the 820-asset capacity, offline functionality and six-month deadline are mandatory pass/fail requirements or weighted preferences. That distinction could change the procurement outcome.
[Assumption] The quoted five-year costs are comparable in scope, taxes, licensing, maintenance and implementation coverage. This needs commercial verification, particularly given Plantwise's escalation clause.
Decision requested: Approve AssetLoop as the preferred bidder for final technical validation and contract negotiation, not yet as an unconditional contract award. Legal should review the exit clauses, and the maintenance lead should validate the requirement scores before the director authorises signature.
