Case 42
Proposal from Discovery Notes
Scenario
You are an account manager at Oakridge Facilities. After two discovery calls, a hospital trust has asked for a proposal for cleaning and porter services by next Wednesday.
Why this framework
Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.
Example context
Discovery call notes (Oakridge Facilities with Ashdown Hospitals NHS Trust, calls on 14 and 21 October 2026): Client contacts: Helen Marsh, Head of Estates; Raj Patel, Procurement. Site: Ashdown General, 3 ward blocks plus outpatients, about 18,000 square metres of cleanable floor. Problem in Helen's words: 'Our current contract misses audit scores on wards every month and porters take too long to move patients to theatre.' Current audit pass mark is 95%; Helen says they are averaging 'high eighties'. Wants: 24/7 cleaning on wards, day cleaning in outpatients, 12 porters on days, 6 on nights, a named on-site manager, monthly audit reporting. Start date wanted: 1 April 2027. Contract length: 3 years with option of 2 more. Out of scope per Helen: theatres cleaning (in-house), waste collection (separate contract). Raj asked for pricing per year and a clear TUPE statement; about 60 existing staff would transfer. Not discussed: deep cleans after infection outbreaks. Rate card (Oakridge 2026/27): ward cleaning £24.50 per hour; outpatients cleaning £21.00 per hour; porter £19.80 per hour; on-site manager £58,000 per year; monthly audit reporting included; outbreak deep clean £1,450 per ward per event; mobilisation fee £35,000 one-off.
Prompt
Purpose: Turn my discovery notes into a first draft proposal the client's procurement team can assess.
Context: Use the attached discovery call notes and our standard rate card. The rate card is the final word on prices. Do not promise anything the notes do not support.
Narrow the ask: A proposal draft with: the client's problem in their words, our proposed scope, what is not included, prices from the rate card, assumptions and risks, and next steps. Clear headings, under 900 words. List any open questions for the client at the end.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Discovery call notes (Oakridge Facilities with Ashdown Hospitals NHS Trust, calls on 14 and 21 October 2026): Client contacts: Helen Marsh, Head of Estates; Raj Patel, Procurement. Site: Ashdown General, 3 ward blocks plus outpatients, about 18,000 square metres of cleanable floor. Problem in Helen's words: 'Our current contract misses audit scores on wards every month and porters take too long to move patients to theatre.' Current audit pass mark is 95%; Helen says they are averaging 'high eighties'. Wants: 24/7 cleaning on wards, day cleaning in outpatients, 12 porters on days, 6 on nights, a named on-site manager, monthly audit reporting. Start date wanted: 1 April 2027. Contract length: 3 years with option of 2 more. Out of scope per Helen: theatres cleaning (in-house), waste collection (separate contract). Raj asked for pricing per year and a clear TUPE statement; about 60 existing staff would transfer. Not discussed: deep cleans after infection outbreaks.
Rate card (Oakridge 2026/27): ward cleaning £24.50 per hour; outpatients cleaning £21.00 per hour; porter £19.80 per hour; on-site manager £58,000 per year; monthly audit reporting included; outbreak deep clean £1,450 per ward per event; mobilisation fee £35,000 one-off.Example output from ChatGPT
DRAFT PROPOSAL | VERSION 0.1 | 2 NOVEMBER 2026
Cleaning and Patient Portering Services Proposal
Prepared by: Oakridge Facilities
Prepared for: Ashdown Hospitals NHS Trust
Site: Ashdown General Hospital
Proposed commencement: 1 April 2027
Contract term: 3 years, with an option to extend for 2 years
For procurement review only. Subject to operational validation, TUPE due diligence and commercial agreement.
1. Understanding Your Requirements
During our discovery discussions on 14 and 21 October 2026, Helen Marsh, Head of Estates, described the Trust's two main challenges:
"Our current contract misses audit scores on wards every month and porters take too long to move patients to theatre."
The current cleaning audit pass mark is 95%, while reported performance averages in the high eighties.
The Trust requires more reliable cleaning coverage, improved patient portering services, clear management accountability and regular performance reporting across Ashdown General Hospital.
2. Proposed Scope of Services
Oakridge Facilities proposes the following service model:
| Service | Proposed scope |
|---|---|
| Ward cleaning | 24-hour, 7-day coverage across three ward blocks |
| Outpatients cleaning | Daytime cleaning coverage |
| Patient portering | 12 porters on days and 6 on nights, subject to confirming whether these are concurrent staffing requirements |
| On-site management | One named on-site manager |
| Performance reporting | Monthly cleaning audit reporting |
Site coverage: Approximately 18,000 m² of cleanable floor space, covering three ward blocks and outpatient areas.
The service will be designed around the Trust's existing 95% cleaning audit pass mark. Achieving that mark, and any patient transfer time commitment, will depend on agreeing baseline performance, staffing requirements and measurable service levels.
3. Exclusions
The following services are excluded from the base proposal:
- Theatre cleaning, which remains in-house.
- Waste collection, covered by a separate contract.
- Deep cleaning following infection outbreaks, pending confirmation of requirements.
Outbreak deep cleaning may be priced separately at the standard rate of £1,450 per ward per event, subject to scope agreement.
4. Commercial Proposal
The following prices are taken directly from Oakridge Facilities' 2026/27 rate card.
| Service | Rate |
|---|---|
| Ward cleaning | £24.50 per hour |
| Outpatients cleaning | £21.00 per hour |
| Patient portering | £19.80 per hour |
| Named on-site manager | £58,000 per year |
| Monthly audit reporting | Included |
| Mobilisation | £35,000 one-off |
Annual pricing basis
- Ward cleaning: £24.50 × agreed annual ward-cleaning hours.
- Outpatients cleaning: £21.00 × agreed annual outpatients-cleaning hours.
- Portering: £19.80 × agreed annual porter hours.
- On-site manager: £58,000 annually.
- Audit reporting: included.
Annual recurring price = cleaning labour + portering labour + £58,000.
Year 1 price = annual recurring price + £35,000 mobilisation fee.
The precise annual price cannot yet be finalised because cleaning staffing levels, outpatients operating hours and portering shift lengths have not been confirmed. No unapproved staffing or hourly assumptions have been used to create a fixed quotation.
5. TUPE and Workforce Transition
Approximately 60 existing employees are expected to transfer.
Oakridge proposes to undertake a formal TUPE assessment as part of mobilisation planning. The commercial and operational implications of any transfer remain subject to employee liability information, employment terms, consultation obligations and appropriate legal review.
This proposal does not confirm that all 60 employees will transfer or that their existing employment costs are fully reflected in the current rate card.
A detailed workforce transition plan will be agreed before contract execution.
6. Assumptions and Risks
| Assumption or risk | Required action |
|---|---|
| Exact cleaning labour requirements are unconfirmed | Agree staffing and coverage schedules |
| Day and night porter shift durations are unclear | Confirm shift lengths and relief requirements |
| Existing workforce costs and obligations are unknown | Complete TUPE due diligence |
| The 95% audit threshold is established, but improvement timing is not | Agree measurement method and service levels |
| Outbreak cleaning requirements have not been discussed | Confirm whether an optional service is required |
| The requested start date depends on mobilisation readiness | Validate the transition timetable |
7. Proposed Next Steps
- Confirm the full staffing model, service hours and site-specific requirements with Helen Marsh.
- Obtain workforce and contract information to support TUPE due diligence.
- Agree audit methodology, performance expectations and portering measures.
- Produce a fully costed annual schedule and three-year contract pricing for Raj Patel's review.
- Finalise mobilisation arrangements for the proposed 1 April 2027 commencement.
8. Open Questions for the Trust
- How many cleaning staff are required on each ward shift, and what are the outpatients operating hours?
- Do the 12 daytime and 6 night-time porters represent simultaneous on-duty headcount? What are their shift lengths?
- What are the current patient transfer times, and what improvement targets should apply?
- Can the Trust provide existing employee details and TUPE information for the approximately 60 affected staff?
- What cleaning audit methodology and performance improvement timetable should be adopted?
- Should outbreak deep cleaning be available as an optional chargeable service?
- What contract indexation, extension, tax and payment terms does Procurement require?
Procurement readiness assessment
Conditional draft: not ready for commercial approval
The proposal covers the requested scope, exclusions, rate-card prices, TUPE statement, risks and next steps.
Three items must be resolved before submission as a firm-priced offer:
- Annual contract value: Cleaning headcount and shift durations are missing, so a reliable annual total cannot be calculated.
- TUPE exposure: Transferring employee costs and liabilities have not been verified.
- Service commitments: The 95% audit threshold is confirmed, but there is no agreed improvement timetable or portering response-time target.
Source check: All quoted prices match the supplied rate card. The draft does not promise an unsupported performance improvement or change any rates.
The next revision should include a confirmed annual pricing schedule for Years 1–3, separately showing the £35,000 mobilisation fee and any agreed extension terms.
