Case 04
Proposal and Project Readiness Review
Proposal
The Client Operations team receives a high volume of service requests through email, forms, and relationship manager submissions. Requests are routed manually by coordinators based on request type and perceived urgency. This creates inconsistent prioritisation and delays during peak periods.
We propose a 10-week improvement project to standardise triage rules, introduce a request categorisation dashboard, and create a daily exception review. The initial focus will be account maintenance, document follow-ups, and standard client servicing requests.
The project will not change the underlying case management system. It will use existing request data exports and a lightweight dashboard for tracking categories, ageing, and ownership. Automation may be considered later, but the first phase is focused on process clarity and visibility.
Known Issues
- No agreed baseline for current triage time.
- Some request categories overlap and may be interpreted differently by teams.
- Risk review is needed for escalation rules, but the reviewer has not been confirmed.
- The dashboard owner after the pilot has not been assigned.
- The pilot success criteria are not yet measurable.
- There is no communication plan for relationship managers who submit requests.
Prompt
Act as a project manager and leadership reviewer.
Review this proposal or project document and tell me whether it is ready to share with leadership.
Extract and assess:
- Business value
- Scope
- Deliverables
- Timeline
- Owners
- Dependencies
- Assumptions
- Risks
- Evidence gaps
- Open questions
- Missing details
- What can be automated, simplified, delegated, or removed
Then provide:
- A readiness assessment
- A table of gaps and recommended fixes
- A practical checklist someone can follow without extra explanation
- Recommended next steps before sharing with leadership
Example output from ChatGPT
Leadership Readiness Review Client Operations | 10-Week Triage Improvement Project AMBER – Not ready for approval Recommendation: The proposal has a credible operational problem, a focused scope and a sensible low-complexity approach. However, it is not yet ready for unconditional leadership approval because the expected value, measurable outcomes, accountability and key controls are undefined.
It is suitable for an early leadership discussion to secure sponsorship and resolve dependencies, but not yet for a full delivery commitment.
1. Readiness scorecard
Indicative readiness score 46/100
Significant gaps Reviewer assessment, not measured data
Business value
2/5
Scope
4/5
Deliverables
3/5
Timeline
2/5
Ownership
1/5
Dependencies and controls
2/5
Success measures
1/5
Adoption and communication
2/5
Scores are qualitative judgments on a five-point scale, weighted equally and normalised to 100.
2. Assessment of proposal components
| Component | Assessment | Leadership concern |
|---|---|---|
| Business value | Partial | Delay reduction is plausible but not quantified |
| Scope | Clear | Three request areas defined; volume and exclusions missing |
| Deliverables | Partial | Rules, dashboard and daily reviews named; acceptance criteria missing |
| Timeline | Partial | 10 weeks proposed; milestones and gates absent |
| Owners | Critical gap | Sponsor, delivery lead, risk reviewer and BAU owner unconfirmed |
| Dependencies | Partial | Data access, quality, risk approval and technical support unresolved |
| Assumptions | Unvalidated | Exports assumed sufficient and consistent |
| Risks | Partial | Issues identified without mitigation or escalation paths |
| Evidence | Critical gap | No baseline, volume data or measurable pilot targets |
| Open questions | Unresolved | Priority definitions, handling of exceptions and ownership |
| Adoption | Missing | RM communication, training and feedback not planned |
Business value The project potentially creates four benefits:
- Efficiency: Less manual interpretation and repeated routing.
- Consistency: Common categorisation and urgency rules.
- Visibility: Clear request ownership, ageing and backlog trends.
- Control: Earlier identification of overdue or misrouted cases. But the proposal currently describes activities rather than measurable business outcomes.
For leadership, the business case should connect: Problem: inconsistent routing and delays
Change: standard rules, dashboard and exception review
Outcome: faster triage, fewer misroutes and less ageing
Evidence: baseline versus pilot performance
3. Gap analysis and recommended fixes
Owners below are proposed roles, not confirmed assignments.
| Priority | Gap | Recommended fix | Proposed owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | No triage baseline | Measure current routing time, error/reassignment rate and overdue volumes | Operations Lead |
| P0 | Unmeasurable success | Agree on KPI definitions, targets and measurement method | Sponsor + PM |
| P0 | Risk reviewer missing | Nominate reviewer and agree escalation-rule approval before pilot | Sponsor |
| P0 | Dashboard BAU owner missing | Assign owner for maintenance, quality and daily operation | Operations Head |
| P0 | No named project owner | Confirm accountable sponsor, PM and workstream owners | Sponsor |
| P1 | Overlapping categories | Create mutually distinguishable categories and a tie-break rule | Operations SME |
| P1 | Data quality unknown | Profile exports for missing fields, freshness and duplicates | Data Lead |
| P1 | No milestone plan | Add weekly deliverables, stage gates and dependencies | PM |
| P1 | RM communication missing | Define communications, training and feedback channel | Change Lead |
| P1 | Resource and cost unclear | Estimate effort, tool costs and operational support | PM + Technology |
| P2 | No handover approach | Document SOP, ownership, monitoring and escalation | Operations Lead |
| P2 | No rollout decision rule | Set criteria for scale, extend, revise or stop | Sponsor |
P0: Resolve before seeking delivery approval. P1: Resolve before pilot execution, with a documented plan at approval. P2: Resolve before pilot closure.
4. Proposed delivery plan
The original document specifies 10 weeks but not how those weeks will be used. This is a recommended baseline schedule, subject to confirmation of resources and approvals. 10-week implementation roadmap Workstream
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Baseline and discovery
Triage rules and approval
Dashboard and data QA
UAT and training
Live pilot
Evaluation and handover
Proposed leadership gates
Week 2: baseline and design accepted. Week 4: rules approved. Week 7: pilot go/no-go. Week 10: rollout decision and BAU acceptance.
Suggested deliverables and acceptance criteria
| Deliverable | Acceptance requirement |
|---|---|
| Current-state baseline | Agreed metrics, definitions, sources and observation period |
| Triage rulebook | Category definitions, precedence, urgency, escalation and exception handling approved |
| Dashboard | Displays category, owner, ageing, priority and unresolved exceptions with reconciled data |
| Daily review SOP | Named reviewer, daily cadence, decision log, escalation and backup coverage |
| Pilot results | Baseline comparison, user feedback, issues and recommendations |
| BAU handover | Named owner, documented operating process and support arrangements |
5. Success measures and evidence requirements
These are illustrative pilot targets, not commitments or findings. Confirm feasibility after establishing the baseline.
| KPI | Baseline | Illustrative target |
|---|---|---|
| Median time to first correct assignment | To measure | 25% reduction |
| Incorrect assignment/reassignment rate | To measure | 30% reduction |
| Requests beyond triage SLA | To measure | 20% reduction |
| Categorisation accuracy on sampled cases | To measure | At least 95% |
| Daily critical exception review completion | To measure | 100% on working days |
| Dashboard record completeness | To measure | At least 98% for required fields |
Define first correct assignment carefully so faster initial routing does not hide downstream rework. Track the 90th-percentile triage time as well as the median, and compare similar request mixes during baseline and pilot periods.
A minimum evidence pack should include historical request volumes by channel/category, age distribution, reassignments, staffing demand and peaks, data-quality findings, and feedback from coordinators and RMs. Without these, leadership cannot judge whether the 10-week investment is proportionate.
6. Main risks and assumptions
| Risk | Likelihood / Impact | Mitigation | Early warning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Poor export quality distorts metrics | Medium / High | Reconcile samples to source records; define freshness thresholds | High missing-field or mismatch rate |
| Ambiguous categories cause misrouting | High / High | Category decision tree; SME testing on historical cases | High reviewer disagreement |
| Escalation rules conflict with policy | Medium / High | Risk approval before go-live | Unresolved control exceptions |
| Dashboard adds duplicate manual work | Medium / Medium | Reuse exports; minimise re-entry | Rising coordinator handling time |
| Pilot fails to change RM behaviour | Medium / High | Early communication and targeted training | Incorrect submissions persist |
| No BAU owner after project | High / High | Assign owner before approval | No handover acceptance |
Likelihood and impact are preliminary ratings based on the proposal's gaps, not a formal risk assessment.
Critical assumptions to validate: required exports are authorised and accessible; request records have reliable timestamps and ownership; the existing system remains the source of truth; daily exceptions can be reviewed with available capacity; and teams can adopt common rules without major policy changes.
Also confirm whether extracts contain sensitive client information, whether dashboard access is role-restricted, and whether retention, audit trails and exception decisions meet internal policy.
7. What to automate, simplify, delegate or remove
Automate later – after rule validation
Categorisation suggestions, ageing calculations, exception flags, data refresh and daily exception summaries are suitable candidates. Start with transparent, rules-based logic where possible. Keep human approval for material escalation decisions.
Simplify immediately
Use one taxonomy, one priority matrix, one dashboard and one exception queue. Avoid introducing separate reports by team or channel when a shared view can meet the need.
Delegate
Coordinators and SMEs can test categories; the data team can validate extracts; Risk can approve escalation controls; an Operations BAU owner can own daily reviews. The PM should retain responsibility for integration, dependencies and delivery reporting.
Remove or defer
Defer predictive routing, case-management replacement, custom workflow engines and extensive dashboard visualisations. These would distract from the first phase's core purpose of improving triage consistency.
8. Leadership questions to answer
- What is the current median and 90th-percentile triage time, and how much delay is attributable to manual routing?
- What service impact and capacity benefit justify this project?
- Who is the accountable executive sponsor and named delivery lead?
- How will urgent requests be recognised, escalated and audited?
- What happens if source exports are incomplete or late?
- Who maintains the dashboard and runs exception reviews after week 10?
- What is the project cost in person-days and other expenses?
- What results would justify expanding, revising or stopping the pilot?
9. Execution-ready checklist
Project readiness action tracker
0 of 20 actions completed
Show remaining
Before leadership submission [ ] Document current request volume and three core delay measures
Proposed owner: Operations Lead
[ ] Confirm executive sponsor, PM and workstream owners
Proposed owner: Sponsor
[ ] Appoint risk reviewer and BAU dashboard owner
Proposed owner: Sponsor
[ ] Define pilot scope, request categories and explicit exclusions
Proposed owner: Operations SME
[ ] Agree measurable KPIs and provisional success thresholds
Proposed owner: Sponsor + PM
[ ] Estimate delivery effort, costs and capacity commitment
Proposed owner: PM + Technology
[ ] Validate extract availability, access and data quality
Proposed owner: Data Lead
[ ] Add key risks, dependencies and mitigation owners
Proposed owner: PM
[ ] Prepare concise decision request for leadership
Proposed owner: PM
Before pilot go-live [ ] Approve triage priority matrix and escalation rules
Proposed owner: Risk + Operations
[ ] Reconcile dashboard output against source records
Proposed owner: Data Lead
[ ] Test overlapping categories and difficult historical cases
Proposed owner: SMEs
[ ] Complete dashboard UAT and access-control checks
Proposed owner: Technology + Operations
[ ] Confirm daily review rota and exception SOP
Proposed owner: Operations Lead
[ ] Communicate process changes to relationship managers
Proposed owner: Change Lead
[ ] Record pilot go/no-go decision
Proposed owner: Sponsor
Before project closure [ ] Compare pilot outcomes against agreed baseline
Proposed owner: PM + Data Lead
[ ] Capture user feedback and unresolved defects
Proposed owner: Change Lead
[ ] Complete dashboard and SOP handover
Proposed owner: BAU Owner
[ ] Obtain scale, extend, revise or stop decision
Proposed owner: Sponsor
Copy checklistReset
10. Recommended next steps
| When | Action | Expected output |
|---|---|---|
| Next 1–2 working days | Sponsor and PM confirm accountability, reviewer and BAU ownership | Named responsibility matrix |
| Next 2–4 working days | Baseline data profiling and current-state measurement | Baseline report and data constraints |
| Next 3–5 working days | Workshop on categories, urgency, exception handling and KPIs | Draft rulebook and measurement plan |
| Before submission | Validate feasibility, resources, timeline, risks and acceptance criteria | Revised proposal with credible delivery plan |
| Leadership meeting | Request a specific decision with conditions and funding/resource asks | Documented go/no-go or conditional endorsement |
These are proposed preparation windows, not agreed deadlines.
11. Improved leadership recommendation
Recommendation: Client Operations Triage Improvement Pilot Decision requested: Endorse the proposed 10-week improvement initiative in principle, subject to confirmation of the baseline, ownership, risk approval and measurable success criteria before execution.
Client Operations currently routes service requests from email, forms and relationship managers through manual triage. This creates inconsistent prioritisation, potentially avoidable reassignments and delays during high-volume periods.
We propose a focused improvement project covering account maintenance, document follow-ups and standard client servicing requests.
The project will deliver:
- Standardised request categories, urgency definitions and escalation rules.
- A lightweight dashboard showing request volume, ownership, ageing and exceptions.
- A daily exception review process with accountable owners.
- A measured pilot, followed by an evidence-based decision on wider rollout. The project will use the existing case management system and available data exports. A system replacement or major automation build is not included.
Expected business outcomes: Reduced triage delays, fewer incorrect assignments, better visibility of overdue requests and more consistent prioritisation. Targets will be confirmed against an agreed baseline.
Key dependencies: Approved triage rules, validated data extracts, named risk reviewer, confirmed delivery resources, dashboard ownership and communication to relationship managers.
Governance: Progress will be reviewed against agreed milestones, with formal approval required before pilot go-live and a final decision on rollout or closure.
Leadership endorsement requested: Confirm the executive sponsor, authorise baseline validation and detailed planning, and nominate the accountable risk and operational owners. The project team will then return with confirmed success measures, resource requirements and a go/no-go recommendation before full pilot execution.
Final verdict Do not submit the original proposal as a request for full project approval. It is a useful concept note, but it lacks the evidence and accountability needed for a sound leadership decision.
My preferred route is to seek conditional endorsement for a short validation stage, close the five P0 gaps, and return with a measurable business case and an accountable delivery plan.
That moves the conversation from “We want to build a dashboard” to “We want to improve service triage, and here is how we will demonstrate that the change delivers value.”
