Case 27
Exception Handling Playbook
Scenario
Your onboarding team regularly hits the same exceptions: missing documents, mismatched names, expired IDs. New staff handle them inconsistently.
Why this framework
Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.
Example context
Onboarding procedure (extract): New customer onboarding at Harbourview Credit Union. Step 1: collect photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months. Step 2: check the name on every document matches the application exactly. Step 3: verify the ID is in date. Step 4: record the check in the case system within one working day. Accounts are not opened until all checks pass. The team lead can approve a 10 working day extension for missing documents; the compliance officer must approve any other departure. Common exceptions (list): missing proof of address; name mismatch (for example Jon and Jonathan, or a married name); expired ID; blurred scans; applicant under 18; address on ID differs from application address.
Prompt
Purpose: Create a simple exception handling guide for new onboarding staff.
Context: Use only the attached onboarding procedure and the list of common exceptions. The procedure wins if anything conflicts.
Narrow the ask: For each exception: how to spot it, what to do, who to escalate to and when. A table, plain language, one page.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Onboarding procedure (extract): New customer onboarding at Harbourview Credit Union. Step 1: collect photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months. Step 2: check the name on every document matches the application exactly. Step 3: verify the ID is in date. Step 4: record the check in the case system within one working day. Accounts are not opened until all checks pass. The team lead can approve a 10 working day extension for missing documents; the compliance officer must approve any other departure.
Common exceptions (list): missing proof of address; name mismatch (for example Jon and Jonathan, or a married name); expired ID; blurred scans; applicant under 18; address on ID differs from application address.Example output from ChatGPT
Harbourview Credit Union
NEW STAFF GUIDE | ONBOARDING EXCEPTION HANDLING | V1.0
Golden rule: Never open an account until all required checks pass. Do not accept exceptions or make changes to the rules without the required approval.
Exception handling table
| Exception | How to spot it | What to do | Escalate to whom and when |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Missing proof of address | Applicant has not provided proof of address dated within the last 3 months. | Request a valid document. Keep the account unopened. | Team lead: When an extension is needed. May approve up to 10 working days. |
| 2. Name mismatch | Name on any document differs from the application (e.g., Jon/Jonathan or married name). | Flag the difference. Ask for clarification and matching documents. Do not assume the names refer to the same person. | Compliance officer: Before accepting any mismatch as an exception. |
| 3. Expired ID | Expiry date on the photo ID has passed. | Request a valid, in-date photo ID. Do not complete verification. | Compliance officer: Before any proposed exception to the valid-ID requirement. |
| 4. Blurred scans | Name, photo, dates or other required details cannot be read clearly. | Request a clear replacement scan. Do not treat unreadable information as verified. | Compliance officer: Before accepting a document that cannot be properly verified. |
| 5. Applicant under 18 | Date of birth shows the applicant is younger than 18. | Flag for review. Do not assume the applicant is eligible or ineligible, as the procedure does not specify an age rule. | Compliance officer: Before proceeding where age-specific handling or a departure from the procedure is proposed. |
| 6. Address differs | Address on the ID differs from the application address. | Check that acceptable proof of address is current and that all names match. Do not assume the address difference is automatically disqualifying. | Compliance officer: Before any exception or departure is needed. |
Rules to follow every time
- Collect: Photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months.
- Check: Names on every document must match the application exactly, and the ID must be in date.
- Record: Enter the check in the case system within one working day.
- Escalate: Team lead for missing-document extensions; compliance officer for any other departure from the procedure.
- Open: Only when every required check has passed.
Important: The procedure does not specify an age eligibility rule, an exception-resolution deadline (other than the approved missing-document extension), or detailed escalation service levels. Staff must not invent these rules. The escalation timings above are practical guidance based on the approval requirements, not stated policy deadlines.
Remember: When in doubt, keep the account unopened and seek the required approval.
