Case 27

Exception Handling Playbook

Scenario

Your onboarding team regularly hits the same exceptions: missing documents, mismatched names, expired IDs. New staff handle them inconsistently.

Why this framework

Uses PIN: what it's for, the context and source of truth, and a narrow ask. Enough for most everyday work.

Example context

Onboarding procedure (extract): New customer onboarding at Harbourview Credit Union. Step 1: collect photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months. Step 2: check the name on every document matches the application exactly. Step 3: verify the ID is in date. Step 4: record the check in the case system within one working day. Accounts are not opened until all checks pass. The team lead can approve a 10 working day extension for missing documents; the compliance officer must approve any other departure. Common exceptions (list): missing proof of address; name mismatch (for example Jon and Jonathan, or a married name); expired ID; blurred scans; applicant under 18; address on ID differs from application address.

Prompt

Purpose: Create a simple exception handling guide for new onboarding staff.

Context: Use only the attached onboarding procedure and the list of common exceptions. The procedure wins if anything conflicts.

Narrow the ask: For each exception: how to spot it, what to do, who to escalate to and when. A table, plain language, one page.

Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Onboarding procedure (extract): New customer onboarding at Harbourview Credit Union. Step 1: collect photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months. Step 2: check the name on every document matches the application exactly. Step 3: verify the ID is in date. Step 4: record the check in the case system within one working day. Accounts are not opened until all checks pass. The team lead can approve a 10 working day extension for missing documents; the compliance officer must approve any other departure.
Common exceptions (list): missing proof of address; name mismatch (for example Jon and Jonathan, or a married name); expired ID; blurred scans; applicant under 18; address on ID differs from application address.

Example output from ChatGPT

Harbourview Credit Union

NEW STAFF GUIDE | ONBOARDING EXCEPTION HANDLING | V1.0

Golden rule: Never open an account until all required checks pass. Do not accept exceptions or make changes to the rules without the required approval.

Exception handling table

ExceptionHow to spot itWhat to doEscalate to whom and when
1. Missing proof of addressApplicant has not provided proof of address dated within the last 3 months.Request a valid document. Keep the account unopened.Team lead: When an extension is needed. May approve up to 10 working days.
2. Name mismatchName on any document differs from the application (e.g., Jon/Jonathan or married name).Flag the difference. Ask for clarification and matching documents. Do not assume the names refer to the same person.Compliance officer: Before accepting any mismatch as an exception.
3. Expired IDExpiry date on the photo ID has passed.Request a valid, in-date photo ID. Do not complete verification.Compliance officer: Before any proposed exception to the valid-ID requirement.
4. Blurred scansName, photo, dates or other required details cannot be read clearly.Request a clear replacement scan. Do not treat unreadable information as verified.Compliance officer: Before accepting a document that cannot be properly verified.
5. Applicant under 18Date of birth shows the applicant is younger than 18.Flag for review. Do not assume the applicant is eligible or ineligible, as the procedure does not specify an age rule.Compliance officer: Before proceeding where age-specific handling or a departure from the procedure is proposed.
6. Address differsAddress on the ID differs from the application address.Check that acceptable proof of address is current and that all names match. Do not assume the address difference is automatically disqualifying.Compliance officer: Before any exception or departure is needed.

Rules to follow every time

  1. Collect: Photo ID and proof of address dated within the last three months.
  2. Check: Names on every document must match the application exactly, and the ID must be in date.
  3. Record: Enter the check in the case system within one working day.
  4. Escalate: Team lead for missing-document extensions; compliance officer for any other departure from the procedure.
  5. Open: Only when every required check has passed.

Important: The procedure does not specify an age eligibility rule, an exception-resolution deadline (other than the approved missing-document extension), or detailed escalation service levels. Staff must not invent these rules. The escalation timings above are practical guidance based on the approval requirements, not stated policy deadlines.

Remember: When in doubt, keep the account unopened and seek the required approval.