Case 21
Handling a Complaint from a Key Client
Scenario
You are a senior relationship manager. A major corporate client has complained that a payment delay caused them a supplier penalty. They want compensation and are threatening to move their accounts.
Why this framework
Uses full PINPOINT because the consequence is higher: adds a professional stance, examples, self-checks, your own review before use, and a plan to tweak and test.
Example context
Complaint (email from Elaine Whitcombe, finance director, Whitcombe & Sons Builders Ltd, 28 October): Says a £86,000 supplier payment instructed on 22 October before the 3pm cut-off did not reach the supplier until 27 October, causing a late-payment penalty of £1,720 and a strained supplier relationship. She asks for compensation, an explanation and assurance it will not recur. She has banked with us for 14 years. Payment operations incident note (internal, 30 October): A batch of CHAPS payments on 22 October was held by a sanctions screening alert on a similarly named beneficiary. The alert was cleared on 24 October but the release was queued behind the weekend and processed on 27 October. The client was not told about the hold. Note does not confirm whether the 3pm cut-off was met; the submission time is recorded as 14:58 in one system and 15:04 in another. Fault is not yet determined. Addendum from Payment Operations (31 October): the 14:58 time comes from the client's online banking log and is the authoritative submission time; the 15:04 time is when the batch file was generated internally, so the instruction met the 3pm cut-off. The client was not told about the sanctions hold, and no one at the bank contacted her between 22 and 27 October. Whether the delay itself was a breach of our service terms is still to be decided by the complaints team. Complaints policy (extract): Acknowledge in writing within 2 working days. Final response within 8 weeks. Relationship managers may apologise for inconvenience and offer to refund bank charges up to £100. Compensation for consequential loss, including third-party penalties, can only be decided by the complaints team after investigation. Never admit liability before the investigation concludes.
Prompt
Purpose: Help me prepare my response and call with a key client who has complained, so we keep the relationship while following our complaints process.
Context: Use the attached complaint, the payment operations incident note, and our complaints policy. The policy is the final word on what I may offer. Do not assume fault until the incident note confirms it.
Narrow the ask: Give me
1. A timeline of what happened from the documents.
2. What we know and do not know about our responsibility.
3. Talking points for the call, including what I must not promise.
4. A short written acknowledgement within policy.
Stop and ask if the incident note and the complaint disagree on key facts.
Persona and role: Act as a seasoned relationship manager: empathetic, honest, careful about liability.
Check your work: For each material claim, label it as [Verified Source], [Inference], [Assumption], or [Unverified]. Cite the source where available. If an unverified or assumed point could materially change the conclusion, flag it for review rather than guessing.
Before I use it: I will check wording with the complaints team and my manager before the call.
Materials (pasted here in place of the attachments):
Complaint (email from Elaine Whitcombe, finance director, Whitcombe & Sons Builders Ltd, 28 October): Says a £86,000 supplier payment instructed on 22 October before the 3pm cut-off did not reach the supplier until 27 October, causing a late-payment penalty of £1,720 and a strained supplier relationship. She asks for compensation, an explanation and assurance it will not recur. She has banked with us for 14 years.
Payment operations incident note (internal, 30 October): A batch of CHAPS payments on 22 October was held by a sanctions screening alert on a similarly named beneficiary. The alert was cleared on 24 October but the release was queued behind the weekend and processed on 27 October. The client was not told about the hold. Note does not confirm whether the 3pm cut-off was met; the submission time is recorded as 14:58 in one system and 15:04 in another. Fault is not yet determined.
Addendum from Payment Operations (31 October): the 14:58 time comes from the client's online banking log and is the authoritative submission time; the 15:04 time is when the batch file was generated internally, so the instruction met the 3pm cut-off. The client was not told about the sanctions hold, and no one at the bank contacted her between 22 and 27 October. Whether the delay itself was a breach of our service terms is still to be decided by the complaints team.
Complaints policy (extract): Acknowledge in writing within 2 working days. Final response within 8 weeks. Relationship managers may apologise for inconvenience and offer to refund bank charges up to £100. Compensation for consequential loss, including third-party penalties, can only be decided by the complaints team after investigation. Never admit liability before the investigation concludes.Example output from ChatGPT
Client Complaint Response & Call Preparation
Client: Elaine Whitcombe, Finance Director, Whitcombe & Sons Builders Ltd Complaint received: 28 October 2026 Amount: £86,000 CHAPS payment Claimed loss: £1,720 supplier penalty Relationship: 14 years
Overall assessment: [Inference] The bank has confirmed that the payment instruction met the cut-off, that sanctions screening delayed processing, and that no communication was made to the client. However, liability for the delay and responsibility for the supplier penalty remain undetermined.
- Timeline of events
| Date | Event | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| 22 October, 14:58 | Client submits £86,000 CHAPS instruction before 3pm cut-off. | [Verified Source] Operations addendum, 31 Oct |
| 22 October, 15:04 | Internal batch file generated. This was not the client's submission time. | [Verified Source] Operations addendum |
| 22 October | Payment batch held by sanctions screening alert involving a similarly named beneficiary. | [Verified Source] Incident note, 30 Oct |
| 24 October | Sanctions alert cleared. Payment release subsequently queued behind the weekend. | [Verified Source] Incident note |
| 27 October | Payment processed; client reports supplier received it on this date. | [Verified Source] Incident note and complaint |
| 28 October | Elaine submits complaint seeking £1,720, an explanation and assurance against recurrence. | [Verified Source] Client complaint |
| 30 October | Internal incident note records uncertainty over submission time and fault. | [Verified Source] Incident note |
| 31 October | Operations confirms 14:58 submission, no client contact and unresolved service-terms question. | [Verified Source] Addendum |
Consistency check: The original 14:58/15:04 discrepancy is resolved by the 31 October addendum. The complaint and incident records do not materially contradict each other on the key facts. The unresolved issue is liability, not the submission time.
- What we know about responsibility
| Issue | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Was the cut-off met? | Yes. [Verified Source] The authoritative online banking log records 14:58. |
| Why was payment held? | [Verified Source] A sanctions screening alert on a similarly named beneficiary. |
| Did the bank contact the client? | No. [Verified Source] Operations confirms no contact between 22 and 27 October. |
| Was the delay a service breach? | Undetermined. [Verified Source] Complaints team must decide. |
| Is the £1,720 penalty payable by the bank? | Undetermined. [Verified Source] Consequential loss compensation requires Complaints investigation and decision. |
| Can the RM apologise? | Yes. [Verified Source] Policy permits an apology for inconvenience without admitting liability. |
| Can the RM refund bank charges? | Up to £100. [Verified Source] Subject to the applicable charges; this authority does not extend to the supplier penalty. |
[Inference] The failure to communicate is a clear customer-service concern even though the underlying payment delay may have involved a necessary compliance control.
[Unverified] The supplier's penalty documentation, the contractual basis for the £1,720 charge and the bank's liability have not been established. These must be reviewed before any compensation decision.
- Call talking points
Opening - acknowledge the relationship
"Elaine, thank you for raising this directly. I understand how disruptive a delayed supplier payment can be, particularly when it affects an important business relationship. I value the trust you've placed in us over the past 14 years."
Confirm what is established
"We've confirmed that your payment instruction was submitted at 2:58pm, before our 3pm cut-off. The payment was held for a screening review and subsequently processed on 27 October."
Address the communication failure
"I am sorry that you were not informed about the delay. I appreciate that this left you without an opportunity to manage your supplier's expectations."
Explain the investigation
"Our complaints team is reviewing the circumstances, including whether our service terms were breached and your request for the £1,720 penalty to be reimbursed. I cannot prejudge their decision, but I will make sure your concerns are presented fully."
Close with a clear next step
"I will ask the complaints team to confirm the next update and ensure you receive the formal response within our complaints process. We will also review what can be improved in how we communicate payment holds."
What you must not promise
| Do not say | Say instead |
|---|---|
| "The bank was at fault." | "Our investigation into responsibility is ongoing." |
| "We'll reimburse your £1,720." | "The complaints team will assess your claim." |
| "This will never happen again." | "We will review the process and any appropriate improvements." |
| "Screening was unnecessary." | "The payment required additional screening." |
| "You'll receive a decision tomorrow." | "We will confirm the next update through our complaints process." |
[Verified Source] The policy prohibits admission of liability before investigation and restricts consequential-loss decisions to the complaints team.
Practical questions for Elaine: [Inference] Ask for the supplier's penalty notice or invoice, whether the supplier relationship has suffered any continuing impact, and whether she needs additional assistance with forthcoming time-sensitive payments. Avoid requesting sensitive third-party information beyond what the complaints process needs.
- Written acknowledgement Acknowledgement of your complaint - CHAPS payment of 22 October Send Recipients
Dear Elaine,
Thank you for your email of 28 October regarding the £86,000 supplier payment.
I am sorry for the inconvenience and concern this delay has caused, particularly given the impact on your supplier relationship.
Our initial review confirms that your instruction was submitted before the 3pm cut-off on 22 October. The payment was subject to additional screening and was processed on 27 October. I also acknowledge that you were not informed of the delay.
Our complaints team is investigating the circumstances, including your request for reimbursement of the £1,720 supplier penalty. No decision on responsibility or compensation has yet been made.
We will keep you informed and provide a final response within eight weeks of receiving your complaint, in accordance with our complaints policy.
We value your 14-year relationship with us and appreciate the opportunity to address your concerns.
Kind regards, Relationship Manager
[Verified Source] The wording follows the supplied complaints policy by acknowledging inconvenience, avoiding admission of liability and referring the penalty claim to the complaints team.
- Actions before contacting the client
Pre-call review checklist
0/5 complete
Confirm whether written acknowledgement was already sent within two working days of 28 October. Have Complaints approve the acknowledgement and call wording, including disclosure of the screening reason. Ask Complaints to investigate the service-terms question and £1,720 claim. Request the supplier penalty evidence through an approved channel. Agree the next client update date and record the call in the complaints case.
Deadline control: [Verified Source] The policy requires acknowledgement within two working days and a final response within eight weeks. Based on the 28 October complaint date, the acknowledgement would ordinarily have been due by 30 October 2026, and the eight-week final-response deadline falls on 23 December 2026, subject to the bank's formal date-counting rules.
[Unverified] No evidence has been supplied that the written acknowledgement was sent. As of 2 November, this is a potential missed deadline requiring immediate verification and escalation if outstanding.
Recommended position: [Inference] Acknowledge the proven facts and the communication shortfall, show genuine concern for the client's supplier relationship, and keep the compensation decision with Complaints. Your strongest relationship-repair action is prompt, dependable communication rather than making an offer you are not authorised to make.
The final email and call wording should be approved by your complaints team and manager before use.
